RulesofCivilProcedure.com Civil Procedure · Every State

De Novo

dē nŏvō · also written de novo review; trial de novo; hearing de novo

Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 12, 2026

Quick answerDe novo means “anew”: a court that reviews something de novo decides the question for itself, as if for the first time, without deferring to the earlier decision.

Pronunciation

There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers and judges say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.

  • Common US legal pronunciation: dee NOH-voh, IPA /ˌdiː ˈnoʊvoʊ/. Many lawyers say the first word DAY, /ˌdeɪ/; both are heard in court.
  • Classical Latin (restored): day NAW-woh, IPA [deː ˈnɔwoː]. Latin v was pronounced like English w, and the o of nŏvō is short in the first syllable and long in the second.

Literal translation

  • de — from, of; here, starting from
  • novo — new; a form of nŏvus

Put together: “from the new,” that is, “anew” or “afresh.”

What it means in law

De novo means starting over. When a court decides a question de novo, it gives the earlier answer no weight and works the question out for itself. The phrase has two main uses.

The first is a standard of review. Appellate courts do not look at every ruling the same way. They review questions of law de novo; findings of fact made by a judge only for clear error; and discretionary rulings, such as most decisions about discovery or trial management, only for abuse of discretion. Federal Rule 52(a)(6) states the fact rule: findings “must not be set aside unless clearly erroneous”. The reason for the difference is practical. Trial judges see the witnesses, so their findings deserve respect; but appellate courts exist to say what the law is, and one court’s reading of a statute or a contract is no better than another’s.

The Supreme Court applied that logic in Salve Regina College v. Russell (1991). Several courts of appeals had deferred to a district judge’s reading of the law of the judge’s own state, on the theory that local judges know local law best. The Court rejected the practice and held that a district court’s determination of state law is reviewed de novo. In Ornelas v. United States (1996) it held that whether known facts amount to reasonable suspicion or probable cause, a mixed question of law and fact, should as a general matter be reviewed de novo, while keeping clear-error review, and due weight, for the underlying facts and the inferences local judges and officers draw from them. That holding covers those two questions; it does not put every mixed question under de novo review.

Trial courts review de novo too. Under Federal Rule 72(b)(3), when a party objects to a magistrate judge’s recommendation on a dispositive matter, the rule is direct: “The district judge must determine de novo any part of the magistrate judge’s disposition that has been properly objected to”. Rule 53(f) gives the same protection when a party objects to a special master’s findings of fact or conclusions of law, though for findings of fact the parties may, with the court’s approval, agree to something less; a master’s rulings on procedural matters are ordinarily set aside only for an abuse of discretion.

The second use is a trial or hearing de novo: a new proceeding in a different tribunal, with new evidence, as though the first had never happened. Many states give a trial de novo on appeal from a small-claims or other limited court, or after nonbinding arbitration, and some statutes give one on review of certain agency decisions.

The two uses are easy to confuse. De novo review on appeal usually takes place on the existing record: the court decides the legal question afresh, but it does not hear new witnesses. A trial de novo starts the whole case again. Courts also call de novo review “plenary” or “independent” review; the words mean the same thing.

Etymology

Dē is a preposition that means from, down from or concerning, and the dictionary’s entry records a set phrase with it, “De integro, anew”. Nŏvus is “new, not old, young, fresh, recent”. One detail is telling. Lewis & Short note that The combination de novo appears only in the contracted form denuo — in classical Latin, writers ran the two words together into a single adverb, denuo, “anew.” The two-word phrase the courts use is a later form; that inference is ours, drawn from the dictionary’s note.

Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries dē, nŏvus, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.

In the opinions

Passages from two Supreme Court majority opinions on de novo review, oldest first. A spaced ellipsis marks where a citation has been left out.

We conclude that a court of appeals should review de novo a district court’s determination of state law. As a general matter, of course, the courts of appeals are vested with plenary appellate authority over final decisions of district courts. . . . The obligation of responsible appellate jurisdiction implies the requisite authority to review independently a lower court’s determinations. Independent appellate review of legal issues best serves the dual goals of doctrinal coherence and economy of judicial administration.

Salve Regina College v. Russell, 499 U.S. 225, 231 (1991) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice Blackmun

A former nursing student sued her college in federal court under state law. The question was how much deference the court of appeals owed the district judge’s reading of that state’s law.

When de novo review is compelled, no form of appellate deference is acceptable.

Salve Regina College v. Russell, 499 U.S. 225, 238 (1991) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice Blackmun

Conceding that the choice of standard rarely changes the outcome of an appeal, the Court said that in the few cases where it does, the difference is real.

We therefore hold that as a general matter determinations of reasonable suspicion and probable cause should be reviewed de novo on appeal. Having said this, we hasten to point out that a reviewing court should take care both to review findings of historical fact only for clear error and to give due weight to inferences drawn from those facts by resident judges and local law enforcement officers.

Ornelas v. United States, 517 U.S. 690, 699 (1996) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Chief Justice Rehnquist

After explaining why appellate courts should decide for themselves whether known facts amount to reasonable suspicion or probable cause, the Court limited the reach of its holding.

Where it appears in the rules

The rule pages below use the phrase in their official text. Most deal with a judge’s review of the work of magistrate judges, masters, commissioners and hearing officers, or with trials de novo after small-claims, justice-court and arbitration decisions. Each link opens the rule with its full verbatim text.

108 rule pages in 35 jurisdictions use “de novo” in their official text.

Notable remarks

This finding of “reasonableness” is precisely what it has told us the appellate court must review de novo; and in de novo review, the “weight due” to a trial court’s finding is zero.

Ornelas v. United States, 517 U.S. 690, 705 (1996) · Supreme Court of the United States · Justice Scalia, dissenting opinion

Dissenting alone, Justice Scalia argued that the majority could not ask appellate courts both to review de novo and to give “due weight” to the trial court’s view, and summed up what de novo review means.

Frequently asked questions

Does de novo review mean a new trial?

No. De novo review on appeal means the appellate court decides a question, usually a question of law, for itself without deferring to the trial court. It normally works from the record already made: no new witnesses, no new evidence. A trial de novo, which some courts allow after a small-claims judgment or nonbinding arbitration, is different. That is a fresh trial.

Which questions get de novo review?

Questions of law, such as the meaning of a statute, a rule or a contract, and whether a jury instruction correctly states the law. Rulings on motions to dismiss and for summary judgment are generally reviewed de novo, because they turn on legal standards. Some mixed questions of law and fact, such as probable cause, are reviewed de novo too. Findings of fact made by a judge are reviewed only for clear error.

How is de novo review different from abuse of discretion?

They sit at opposite ends of a scale. Under de novo review, the appellate court substitutes its own judgment for the lower court’s. Under abuse-of-discretion review, it reverses only if the lower court’s decision was outside the range of reasonable choices or rested on a legal error. Most rulings about managing a case, such as scheduling, discovery disputes and many evidence rulings, get abuse-of-discretion review.

Can new evidence be offered on de novo review?

Usually not on appeal: appellate courts decide on the record. Elsewhere it varies. A district judge reviewing a magistrate judge’s recommendation de novo under Federal Rule 72(b)(3) may receive further evidence, and in a trial de novo the parties present their evidence afresh.

Are “plenary review” and “independent review” the same as de novo?

Yes, for practical purposes. Courts use all three terms for review that gives no deference to the decision below. The Supreme Court’s opinion in Salve Regina College v. Russell uses them interchangeably.

This page explains a legal term. It is legal information, not legal advice, and it cannot tell you how the law applies to your situation. If the outcome matters, talk to a lawyer or your court’s self-help center.