(a) The determination of the amount in controversy, under subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 1141.11, shall be made by the court and the case referred to arbitration after all named parties have appeared or defaulted. The determination shall be made at a case management conference or based upon review of the written submissions of the parties, as provided in rules adopted by the Judicial Council. The determination shall be based on the total amount of damages, and the judge may not consider questions of liability or comparative negligence or any other defense. At that time the court shall also make a determination whether any prayer for equitable relief is frivolous or insubstantial. The determination of the amount in controversy and whether any prayer for equitable relief is frivolous or insubstantial may not be appealable. No determination pursuant to this section shall be made if all parties stipulate in writing that the amount in controversy exceeds the amount specified in Section 1141.11.
§ 1141.16.Determination of Amount In Controversy
Title 3. Of Summary Proceedings · Chapter 2.5. Judicial Arbitration · Last amended 2005 · Last verified July 29, 2026
In one sentenceSection 1141.16 has the court, not the arbitrator, determine the amount in controversy after all parties have appeared based only on total damages claimed, makes that determination unappealable and without prejudice to later valuation, and generally bars the arbitration hearing itself from occurring until 210 or 240 days after the complaint was filed absent specified exceptions.
Full Text of § 1141.16
(b) The determination and any stipulation of the amount in controversy shall be without prejudice to any finding on the value of the case by an arbitrator or in a subsequent trial de novo.
(c) Except as provided in this section, the arbitration hearing may not be held until 210 days after the filing of the complaint, or 240 days after the filing of a complaint if the parties have stipulated to a continuance pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 68616 of the Government Code. A case shall be submitted to arbitration at an earlier time upon any of the following:
(1) The stipulation of the parties to an earlier arbitration hearing.
(2) The written request of all plaintiffs, subject to a motion by a defendant for good cause shown to delay the arbitration hearing.
(3) An order of the court if the parties have stipulated, or the court has ordered under Section 1141.24, that discovery other than that permitted under Chapter 18 (commencing with Section 2034.010) of Title 4 of Part 4 will be permitted after the arbitration award is rendered.
Plain-English Summary
Two separate gatekeeping jobs live in this section: deciding how much is at stake, and deciding when the arbitration can happen. Subdivision (a) puts the amount-in-controversy call in the court's hands, made after every named party has appeared or defaulted, either at a case management conference or from the parties' written submissions under Judicial Council rules. The court looks only at total damages claimed, not liability, not comparative negligence, not any other defense, and at the same time decides whether a prayer for equitable relief is frivolous or insubstantial under § 1141.13. Neither determination can be appealed, and the court skips making one at all if every party stipulates in writing that the amount in controversy exceeds § 1141.11's threshold.
Subdivision (b) makes clear this early determination doesn't bind anyone later — it's without prejudice to whatever value an arbitrator or a jury at a trial de novo eventually finds the case to be worth.
Subdivision (c) sets the clock for the hearing itself: absent an exception, it can't happen until 210 days after the complaint was filed, or 240 days if the parties stipulated to a continuance under Government Code § 68616(d). Three things can move the hearing up: the parties' stipulation, a written request from all plaintiffs, though a defendant can move for good cause to delay it anyway, or a court order allowing post-award discovery beyond expert discovery under § 1141.24.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who decides the amount in controversy for judicial arbitration purposes?
The court, not the arbitrator, based solely on the total amount of damages claimed, without considering liability or comparative negligence.
Can a party appeal the court's amount-in-controversy determination?
No. Section 1141.16(a) makes that determination, and the related finding on frivolous or insubstantial equitable relief, unappealable.
Does the court's early determination bind the arbitrator's valuation of the case?
No. Section 1141.16(b) makes it without prejudice to any finding on the case's value by an arbitrator or at a trial de novo.
How soon after filing can the arbitration hearing take place?
Not before 210 days after the complaint is filed, or 240 days if the parties stipulated to a continuance, unless one of the exceptions in subdivision (c) applies.
What can move the arbitration hearing up sooner than that?
A stipulation of the parties, a written request from all plaintiffs, subject to a defendant's good-cause motion to delay, or a court order permitting post-award discovery under § 1141.24.
Amendment History
Amended by Stats 2004 ch 182 (AB 3081),s 14, eff. 7/1/2005 Amended by Stats 2003 ch 449 (AB 1712),s 12, eff. 1/1/2004.
Source & verification. Section text is reproduced verbatim from
the Deering's California Codes Annotated / vLex. Enacted by the California Legislature.
Last verified July 29, 2026.
· Official source
Also known as: amount in controversy judicial arbitration californiawhen is arbitration hearing scheduled california