Mesne Profits
mesne profits
Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 16, 2026
Pronunciation
There is no single official pronunciation, but this one is settled: the s in mesne is silent.
- Common US legal pronunciation: MEEN PROF-its, IPA /ˈmiːn ˈprɒfɪts/. Mesne sounds exactly like the English word mean.
- No classical form: Mesne is Law French, the French once used in English courts, not Latin, so there is no restored Roman pronunciation to give.
Literal translation
- mesne — middle, intermediate; here, in between in time
- profits — benefits, income; here, what land yields, such as rent and crops
Put together: “the profits of the time in between,” that is, the income of the land for the period between the owner’s loss of possession and its recovery. Mesne is not Latin. It comes from Law French, the language English lawyers and courts used for centuries after the Norman Conquest; the Etymology section below gives the sources. The same word survives in mesne lord, a lord in the middle of the feudal ladder, and in mesne process, process issued in the middle of a lawsuit.
What it means in law
When someone takes or keeps land that belongs to another, the owner suffers two losses. The first is the land itself. The second is everything the land would have produced while the owner was shut out: the rent a tenant would have paid, the crops, the timber, or simply the value of using it. The second loss is the mesne profits.
At common law the two losses were usually recovered in two steps. The owner first brought ejectment, the action for recovering possession of land, in which the damages awarded were ordinarily nominal. Having won the land back, the owner then sued the wrongful possessor in a separate action for the mesne profits. The Supreme Court’s account of an earlier ejectment case in Kountze v. Omaha Hotel Co. (1883) shows the pattern: the case was over mining land, and only nominal damages had been given. The losses the owner would suffer from being kept out of possession during an appeal, the Court had said there, belonged to an action for mesne profits.
Mesne profits are generally measured by the value of the land’s use during the wrongful possession, such as its rental value or the rents and profits the possessor took. Statutes adjust the figure in different ways. Illinois lets the defendant set off improvements made on the land, to the extent the courts allow. Virginia lets the ejectment jury assess mesne profits for a period that begins no more than five years before the suit was filed and runs up to the verdict. Illinois also spares a person who took peaceable possession under a clear record title, without notice of the adverse claim, from paying rents and profits for the time before that notice. The details are set by each state’s statutes.
Many states have also changed the procedure. Illinois lets the plaintiff claim mesne profits by a petition filed in the ejectment case itself, within a year after the judgment, instead of in a separate action. New Jersey’s rules say the opposite in effect: a judgment for possession does not bar a later action for mesne profits and damages. California gives an action for mesne profits its own five-year limitations period.
Whether the claim survives the death of a party has also mattered. In Henshaw v. Miller (1855) the Supreme Court held, applying Virginia law, that a suit for fraud brought in the federal court in Virginia abated when the defendant died. The plaintiff relied on a Virginia decision letting an action for mesne profits go on against a dead defendant’s executor. Justice Daniel suggested the Virginia court may have treated that claim as resting on an implied obligation to account for the profits, more like a contract than a wrong, and so set it apart. Oklahoma’s survival statute now lists actions for mesne profits by name among those that survive.
Etymology
Mesne profits is Law French, the French that English lawyers and courts used for centuries after the Norman Conquest, though profits has long been plain English.
Mesne is an old spelling of a word for “middle.” Robert Kelham’s Dictionary of the Norman or Old French Language (1779), compiled for readers of the old statutes and law books, glosses a la mesne as “in the middle”. The Anglo-Norman Dictionary, the standard dictionary of the French written in medieval England, lists mesne among the forms of the word it heads mene. Its senses run from the middle of a place to the middle of a ladder of rank, the mesne lord, and to the middle of a span of time: “intermediate in time, occurring between two other events”. Under the phrase mene temps, “the meantime,” the entry gives examples that speak of the profits of land taken or lost in the meantime, including one from 1481 in which a tenant recovers damages because he lost the land’s profits in the meantime.
Profits comes from the Law French profit. Kelham glosses les profites as “the advantages, benefits”, and the Anglo-Norman Dictionary gives the word the senses “benefit, advantage” and, in money matters, “profit, income”.
Put together, the phrase names the income of the meantime: what the land produced between the owner’s loss and its recovery.
Sources: Robert Kelham, A Dictionary of the Norman or Old French Language (1779), entries Mesne (a la) (p. 152), Profites (les) (p. 193), from the scan at the Internet Archive; and the Anglo-Norman Dictionary (Aberystwyth University), entries mene 1, profit, which is described here in our own words except for the few words quoted. Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from these sources.
In the opinions
Two Supreme Court passages, each showing what the action for mesne profits was for. Neither is a one-line definition; the Court used the phrase as a term everyone knew. Each is quoted from the official United States Reports. The space before the semicolon in the first passage is printed that way in the official report.
The court refused the motion; and said that if it were a money demand, on which a sum certain had been given by a judgment, it would have been the duty of the judge to take care that good security was given ; but that in ejectment, where only nominal damages are recovered, the court cannot interfere to enlarge the security to recover damages which a plaintiff may recover in an action for mesne profits, or other losses he will sustain by being kept out of possession.
In a suit on an appeal bond, Justice Bradley surveyed what such bonds had been held to secure. Here he describes the Court’s earlier decision in Roberts v. Cooper (1857), an ejectment case over mining land, in which the winning plaintiff had asked for more security on the loser’s appeal. “The court” is the Court in Roberts.
It is the case of Lee v. Cooke’s Executor, reported in Gilmer, 331. This was an action for mesne profits of land which had been recovered in ejectment.
Deciding whether a suit survived the defendant’s death, Justice Daniel turned to the one Virginia case the plaintiff relied on, in which the state’s highest court had let an action for mesne profits proceed against the executor.
Where it appears in the rules
The rule pages below use the phrase in their official text or title. Most are statutes or court rules on ejectment and actions to recover land, in Georgia, Illinois, New Jersey, Oklahoma and Virginia: how mesne profits are claimed, tried and limited. Others set a limitations period (California) or say that such a claim survives a party’s death (Nebraska and Oklahoma). Each link opens the rule with its full verbatim text.
13 rule pages in 7 jurisdictions use “mesne profits” in their official text.
California 1
Illinois 5
Oklahoma 2
Three of them show how differently states handle the claim. Illinois’s 735 ILCS 5/6-133 provides: “Instead of a separate action for the recovery of mesne profits, the plaintiff seeking to recover such damages shall, within one year after the entering of the judgment, file a petition in the ejectment action.” New Jersey’s Rule 4:42-5 keeps the separate action open, and California’s Code of Civil Procedure § 336(a) sets five years for “An action for mesne profits of real property.”
Frequently asked questions
What are mesne profits?
The income or value of land that an owner lost while someone else wrongfully held it, such as the rent the land would have earned. The owner recovers them from the wrongful possessor after establishing the right to the land.
How do you pronounce mesne?
Like the English word mean: MEEN. The s is silent, as it is in many words that came into English from old French.
Are mesne profits the same as damages for trespass?
They are related but not the same. Mesne profits are a particular measure of loss: the value of the land’s use during the wrongful possession. A claim may also include other damages, such as waste or harm done to the buildings, which rules like Virginia’s § 8.01-158 assess alongside the mesne profits.
Do I have to bring a separate lawsuit for mesne profits?
It depends on the state. Under the old common law the owner usually won possession in ejectment first and then sued separately for the mesne profits. Some states now require or allow the claim in the same case; Illinois, for example, has the plaintiff file a petition in the ejectment action within a year after judgment. Others, such as New Jersey, expressly leave room for a later action.
Is there a deadline for claiming mesne profits?
Yes, though it varies. California’s Code of Civil Procedure gives an action for mesne profits of real property five years, and Illinois’s petition procedure must be used within one year after the ejectment judgment. Some states also limit how far back the profits can reach, which is a different question: Virginia’s ejectment jury may assess profits from no more than five years before the suit up to its verdict. The statutes of the state where the land lies control.