RulesofCivilProcedure.com Civil Procedure · Every State

Sub Silentio

sub sĭlentĭō

Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 13, 2026

Quick answerSub silentio means “in silence”: a point a court decided, assumed or passed over without anyone raising it or the opinion discussing it, which is why such a point is generally not treated as precedent.

Pronunciation

There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.

  • Common US legal pronunciation: sub sih-LEN-shee-oh, IPA /ˌsʌb sɪˈlɛnʃioʊ/. Some say sub sih-LEN-tee-oh, /sɪˈlɛntioʊ/.
  • Classical Latin (restored): sub sih-LEN-tee-oh, IPA [sʊb sɪˈlɛntɪoː]. The u of sub is short, as in put, the t stays hard, and the final ō is long.

Literal translation

  • sub — under
  • silentio — silence; the form of silentium that follows sub

Put together: “under silence,” or in plain English, “without anything being said.”

What it means in law

Courts use sub silentio for something done without being said. A court that exercises jurisdiction without anyone questioning it has assumed its jurisdiction sub silentio. A later decision that cannot be squared with an earlier one, but never mentions it, is sometimes said to have overruled it sub silentio. The phrase matters because of what follows from that silence.

Silent rulings are not precedent. A case is authority for what it decides, and a court decides only what is put to it and what it actually considers. A point that sat in the record unnoticed, raised by no party and discussed in no opinion, was not decided in a way that binds later courts. The Supreme Court stated the principle in plain English in Webster v. Fall (1925), and it has applied it even to its own power to hear cases. In United States v. L. A. Tucker Truck Lines, Inc. (1952) and Hagans v. Lavine (1974), the Court said it is not bound by earlier cases that exercised jurisdiction without anyone questioning it. A dissent in a later case traced the idea to a remark by Chief Justice Marshall in 1805.

Precedent is not overruled in silence. The rule also works the other way. The Supreme Court does not normally overrule or sharply narrow its own earlier decisions without saying so, and it reads its later cases on that assumption. In Shalala v. Illinois Council on Long Term Care, Inc. (2000) the Court refused to read a 1986 decision as having silently cut back earlier ones. A litigant who argues that a precedent was overruled sub silentio carries a heavy burden.

The two halves fit together. An earlier case binds on what it decided, not on what it merely assumed; and a later case changes the law only where it says it does. Both protect the same value, that the law should be made by considered decisions rather than by accident.

Sub silentio is easy to confuse with arguendo. A court that assumes a point arguendo says so openly and leaves the point undecided. A point passed sub silentio is assumed without a word. Both leave the question open for a later case, but only one warns the reader.

The phrase is a tool for reading opinions, and it appears in no rule text on this site.

Etymology

Sub is a preposition that, with the case used here, means “under, below, beneath, underneath”. Silentio is a form of silentium, which Lewis & Short gloss “a being still or silent, noiselessness, stillness, silence”. The dictionary records the classical idiom praeterire silentio, glossed “to pass over in silence, to say nothing about”, which is the sense courts mean.

The saved entries do not record sub silentio itself. Read literally it means “under silence,” and the legal sense, a matter passed over without discussion, is ours to draw from that reading and from the idiom above.

Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries sŭb, sĭlentĭum, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.

In the opinions

Three Supreme Court passages, oldest first. The first states the principle without using the Latin; the others use the phrase. A fourth, the footnote in Hagans v. Lavine (1974) that later cases often quote, runs across three printed pages in a way this site’s checking tools cannot yet confirm, so it is described above rather than quoted. Each is quoted from the official United States Reports; a spaced ellipsis marks where a citation or a footnote number has been left out.

Counsel for appellant directs our attention to other cases, where this Court proceeded to determine the merits notwithstanding the suits were brought against inferior or subordinate officials without joining the superior. We do not stop to inquire whether all or any of them can be differentiated from the case now under consideration, since in none of them was the point here at issue suggested or decided. The most that can be said is that the point was in the cases if anyone had seen fit to raise it. Questions which merely lurk in the record, neither brought to the attention of the court nor ruled upon, are not to be considered as having been so decided as to constitute precedents.

Webster v. Fall, 266 U.S. 507, 511 (1925) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice Sutherland

A member of the Osage Tribe had sued the Secretary of the Interior and two subordinate officials, but only the subordinates were served. The Court held that the Secretary was a necessary party. The tribe member’s lawyer pointed to earlier cases that had reached the merits in suits against subordinate officials alone, and the Court explained why they did not settle the point.

The effect of the omission was not there raised in briefs or argument nor discussed in the opinion of the Court. Therefore, the case is not a binding precedent on this point. . . . Even as to our own judicial power or jurisdiction, this Court has followed the lead of Mr. Chief Justice Marshall who held that this Court is not bound by a prior exercise of jurisdiction in a case where it was not questioned and it was passed sub silentio.

United States v. L. A. Tucker Truck Lines, Inc., 344 U.S. 33, 38 (1952) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice Jackson

A trucking company had raised no objection before the agency to a defect in a hearing examiner’s appointment, and argued that an earlier decision showed such a defect voided the agency’s order anyway. The Court said the earlier case had never considered whether the objection there was made in time.

This Court does not normally overturn, or so dramatically limit, earlier authority sub silentio. And we agree with those Circuits that have held the Court did not do so in this instance.

Shalala v. Illinois Council on Long Term Care, Inc., 529 U.S. 1, 18 (2000) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice Breyer

A court of appeals had read a 1986 decision as sharply limiting earlier ones that required certain Medicare and Social Security claims to go through the agency before reaching court. The Court rejected that reading.

Where it appears in the rules

No rule on this site uses “sub silentio” in its official text.

Notable remarks

Two dissents in which Justices comment on the doctrine itself.

The source of this doctrine that jurisdictional issues decided sub silentio are not binding in other cases seems to be Mr. Chief Justice Marshall’s remark in United States v. More, 3 Cranch 159, 172 (1805). . . . While the Chief Justice also said that such decisions may “have much weight, as they show that this point neither occurred to the bar or the bench,” . . . unconsidered assumptions of jurisdiction simply cannot outweigh four consistent decisions of this Court, explicitly considering and rejecting that jurisdiction.

Monell v. Department of Social Services of City of New York, 436 U.S. 658, 716 (1978) · Supreme Court of the United States · Justice Rehnquist, dissenting opinion

Dissenting, with Chief Justice Burger, from the decision that cities can be sued under the federal civil-rights statute, Justice Rehnquist traced the doctrine to its source and argued about how much weight unexamined decisions deserve.

But it is one thing to conclude that the result in Ringer would have been different had we applied Michigan Academy’s § 1395ii analysis to that case; it is quite another to declare that Michigan Academy effected a sub silentio overruling of Ringer. Contrary to the majority’s representation, ante, at 18, my approach entails only the former, and therefore does not offend stare decisis principles as a sub silentio overruling would.

Shalala v. Illinois Council on Long Term Care, Inc., 529 U.S. 1, 41 (2000) · Supreme Court of the United States · Justice Thomas, dissenting opinion

Answering the majority’s charge that his reading would overrule an earlier case, Justice Thomas drew a line between saying an old case would come out differently today and saying a later case silently overruled it.

Frequently asked questions

What does sub silentio mean in plain English?

“In silence,” or “without saying so.” Lawyers use it for something a court did, assumed or decided without discussing it, such as hearing a case without anyone questioning whether it had jurisdiction.

Is a decision made sub silentio binding precedent?

Generally not, on the point that was passed over. A case is authority for what the court actually considered and decided. If a question was never raised and never discussed, later courts usually treat it as open, as the Supreme Court has done even with questions of its own jurisdiction.

What does it mean to overrule a case sub silentio?

To decide a later case in a way that cannot be reconciled with an earlier one, without saying the earlier one is overruled. The Supreme Court has said it does not normally do this, so courts are slow to find that a precedent was overruled silently. Until a court says so, the earlier decision is generally treated as still standing.

How is sub silentio different from obiter dictum?

Obiter dictum is something a court said that was not needed for its decision; it is spoken but not binding. Something passed sub silentio was not said at all. Neither is a binding holding on the point, but for opposite reasons.

How is sub silentio different from arguendo?

A court that assumes a point arguendo announces that it is doing so, and leaves the point undecided. A point assumed sub silentio is taken for granted without comment. Both leave the question open for a later case.

This page explains a legal term. It is legal information, not legal advice, and it cannot tell you how the law applies to your situation. How much weight an earlier decision carries on a point it did not discuss depends on the court, the point and the law of the jurisdiction. If the outcome matters, talk to a lawyer or your court’s self-help center.