RulesofCivilProcedure.com Civil Procedure · Every State

Obiter Dictum

ŏbĭter dictum · also written obiter dicta (plural); dictum; dicta; obiter

Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 12, 2026

Quick answerObiter dictum, usually shortened to “dictum,” is a statement in a court opinion that was not necessary to decide the case; later courts may find it persuasive, but they are not bound to follow it.

Pronunciation

There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers and judges say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.

  • Common US legal pronunciation: OH-bih-ter DIK-tum, IPA /ˈoʊbɪtər ˈdɪktəm/. Some say the first word AH-bih-ter, /ˈɑːbɪtər/. The plural, dicta, is DIK-tuh, /ˈdɪktə/.
  • Classical Latin (restored): OB-ih-tehr DIK-toom, IPA [ˈɔbɪtɛr ˈdɪktʊm]. The first syllable of obiter is short, and the stress falls on it.

Literal translation

  • obiter — “by the way,” “in passing”; an adverb
  • dictum — “something said”; the past participle of dīco, “to say,” used as a noun

Put together: “something said by the way,” a remark made in passing.

What it means in law

A court’s opinion does two things. It decides the case in front of it, and it explains why. Along the way it often says more than the decision needs: it describes how the rule might apply to other facts, comments on an argument no one pressed, or states a principle broader than the dispute requires. Those extra statements are obiter dicta, usually just called dicta (one statement is a dictum).

The line matters because of precedent. Under stare decisis, the holding of a case, the rule of law necessary to reach its result, is the part that binds: lower courts must follow it, and the court that decided it departs from it only for strong reasons. Dicta do not carry that weight. A later court may find a dictum wise and adopt it, but it is free to decide otherwise, and a lower court is not bound by a higher court’s dictum the way it is bound by a holding.

Why the difference? Chief Justice Marshall gave the classic answer in Cohens v. Virginia (1821), where Virginia relied on broad language in Marbury v. Madison. Marshall said that general statements in an opinion must be read in light of the case that produced them. The question actually before a court is argued and examined with care; statements that reach past it are seldom tested the same way. So they may be respected, but they should not control a later case in which the point is squarely presented.

Telling holding from dictum is not always easy. The usual test asks whether the statement was necessary to the result: if the court could have struck it from the opinion and still decided the case the same way, it is likely dictum. Two refinements limit that test. When a court rests its judgment on two independent grounds, each is a holding, not dictum, even though either would have been enough. And a distinct ruling on a question that fairly arose and was decided is a holding, even if the court might have disposed of the case some other way.

Courts also speak of judicial dictum, a statement the court plainly considered with care though it was not strictly necessary. Many lower courts give carefully considered dicta from the Supreme Court great weight, and some say they should rarely depart from it. The label is not a license to ignore a higher court’s reasoning; it marks how far that reasoning binds.

Obiter dictum is the counterpart of ratio decidendi, the reason for the decision, which English and some American courts use for what Americans more often call the holding. It is not related to res judicata, which binds the parties to a judgment’s result regardless of what the opinion says.

Etymology

Obiter is an adverb that Lewis & Short gloss as “on the way, in going or passing along”, and in its transferred sense as “By the way, in passing, incidentally”. Dictum is the noun formed from the verb dīco, to say; the dictionary’s short entry for dictum sends the reader to that verb, where the noun is glossed “something said, i. e. a saying, a word”.

Joined, the two words describe a remark dropped on the way to somewhere else, which is just what a court’s dictum is: said on the road to the decision, but not part of it. That gloss of the legal phrase is ours; the dictionary defines only the Latin words.

Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries ŏb-ĭter, dīco, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.

In the opinions

Two Supreme Court passages, the older one first: one on where the line between holding and dictum falls, and a dissent on what dictum is worth. Each is quoted from the official United States Reports.

Of course, where there are two grounds, upon either of which the judgment of the trial court can be rested, and the appellate court sustains both, the ruling on neither is obiter, but each is the judgment of the court and of equal validity with the other. Whenever a question fairly arises in the course of a trial, and there is a distinct decision of that question, the ruling of the court in respect thereto can, in no just sense, be called mere dictum.

Union Pacific Railroad Co. v. Mason City & Fort Dodge Railroad Co., 199 U.S. 160, 166 (1905) · Supreme Court of the United States

Writing for the Court, Justice Brewer rejected the argument that part of an earlier decision about the same bridge was mere dictum, because that decision had rested on two grounds and decided both.

Dictum, though not precedent, may have its utility; but it ought not to be treated as a judgment standing on its own.

Camreta v. Greene, 563 U.S. 692, 716 (2011) · Supreme Court of the United States · Justice Kennedy, dissenting opinion

The Court held that government officials who had won on qualified immunity could still ask it to review the lower court’s ruling that their conduct was unconstitutional. Justice Kennedy, dissenting, saw that ruling as unnecessary to the judgment and objected to treating it as something a winning party could appeal.

Where it appears in the rules

No rule on this site uses “obiter dictum” in its official text.

That is no surprise: the line between holding and dictum is drawn by judges reading opinions, not by court rules.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a holding and dictum?

The holding is the rule of law the court needed to decide the case. Under stare decisis it is the part that binds: lower courts must follow it, and the same court departs from it only for strong reasons. Dictum is anything else the opinion says along the way: observations, examples, or broader statements the result did not depend on. A later court may follow dictum because it is persuasive, but it does not have to.

Is dictum ever binding?

Not in the strict sense. But it can carry real weight. Many lower courts treat carefully considered statements of the Supreme Court as highly persuasive and depart from them only for good reason. A court that ignores a higher court’s considered dictum risks being reversed if the higher court later turns its dictum into a holding.

How do judges decide whether a statement is dictum?

The usual question is whether the statement was necessary to the result. If the case would have come out the same way without it, it is probably dictum. Two exceptions narrow that test: when a judgment rests on two independent grounds, both are holdings, and a distinct ruling on a question the case squarely raised is a holding even if the court could have decided the case another way.

What does “obiter” mean on its own?

It is the first word of the phrase, “by the way.” In Latin it is an adverb. Lawyers sometimes use it alone, as an adjective (“an obiter remark”) or an adverb (“said obiter”), to mark a statement as dictum.

Is the plural “obiter dicta” or “obiter dictums”?

Obiter dicta. Dictum is a Latin neuter noun, and its plural is dicta. “Dictums” is sometimes seen but is rare in legal writing.

This page explains a legal term. It is legal information, not legal advice, and it cannot tell you how the law applies to your situation. If the outcome matters, talk to a lawyer or your court’s self-help center.