Pro Tanto
prō tantō
Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 13, 2026
Pronunciation
There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.
- Common US legal pronunciation: proh TAN-toh, IPA /ˌproʊ ˈtæntoʊ/. Some say TAHN-toh, /ˈtɑːntoʊ/.
- Classical Latin (restored): proh TAHN-toh, IPA [proː ˈtantoː]. Both final vowels are long: prō always, and tantō because it is in the ablative case.
Literal translation
- pro — for, in proportion to, according to
- tanto — so much; the ablative tantō of the adjective tantus, “so great”
Put together: “for so much,” or more naturally, “to that extent.”
What it means in law
Pro tanto is a phrase of measurement. Something happens pro tanto when it happens only to the extent of a stated amount, not in full. A lien extinguished pro tanto is wiped out as far as the money paid reaches, and no further. A right transferred pro tanto passes only to the extent of what the transferee paid for it.
The phrase does its most important work in settlement law. Suppose a plaintiff sues two defendants who are both liable for the same injury, and one settles before trial. If the plaintiff later wins against the other, the court has to decide how the settlement affects the judgment. The Supreme Court, in McDermott, Inc. v. AmClyde (1994), adopted a common way of sorting the answers into three main approaches:
- A pro tanto credit with contribution: the judgment against the defendant who went to trial is reduced by the dollar amount of the settlement, and that defendant may still sue the settling defendant for contribution.
- A pro tanto credit without contribution: the same dollar-for-dollar reduction, but the settling defendant is released from contribution claims.
- The proportionate-share approach: the judgment is reduced by the settling defendant’s share of fault, as found at trial, whatever the settlement amount.
The difference matters. Under a pro tanto credit, the defendant who went to trial can end up paying more than its share of fault if the other defendant settled cheaply, or less if the other paid generously. The Court gave a simple example: two equally responsible defendants, one settling for $250,000, and damages of $1 million at trial. The pro tanto rule leaves the defendant who went to trial owing $750,000, three-quarters of the damages for half the fault.
In McDermott, a federal admiralty case, the Court chose the proportionate-share approach. It found that approach most consistent with the rule that admiralty damages follow comparative fault, and it rejected the first option as clearly inferior because it discourages settlement and invites further litigation. The Court acknowledged that the pro tanto rule puts extra pressure on defendants to settle, but it thought that pressure unnecessary and too unfair.
That holding governs federal maritime cases. Outside admiralty, the answer depends on the statute or case law that governs the claim, and the rules differ from state to state. Some states give a pro tanto credit and protect the nonsettling defendant by requiring that the settlement be made in good faith; others use the proportionate-share approach, and some combine features of both.
Outside settlements the phrase keeps its plain sense. A court may say a payment satisfies a judgment pro tanto, meaning to the extent of the payment, or that an official acts pro tanto for the government, meaning so far as he acts for it. It should not be confused with pro rata, which means in proportion to shares. A pro rata division splits something by percentages; a pro tanto credit subtracts a fixed amount.
Etymology
Prō is a preposition of many senses. In its most general one, relating one thing to another, Lewis & Short give “in proportion, in comparison with, according to or as, conformably to, by virtue of, for”. Tantō is the ablative of the adjective tantus, “Of such size or measure, so great in amount, extent, value, degree, etc.” The dictionary also records the ablative tantō with comparatives, meaning “by so much, so much the”.
Neither saved entry records pro tanto as a fixed phrase. Read together, the words mean “for so great an amount,” and from there “to that extent”; that reading is ours, not the dictionary’s. The legal sense keeps the measuring idea of tantus: the effect reaches exactly as far as the amount named.
Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries prō, tantus, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.
In the opinions
Three passages from the Supreme Court’s main treatment of the pro tanto settlement credit. Each is quoted from the official United States Reports; a spaced ellipsis marks where a footnote number has been left out.
The first two alternatives involve the kind of “pro tanto” credit that respondents urge us to adopt. The difference between the two versions of the pro tanto approach is the recognition of a right of contribution against a settling defendant in the first but not the second.
Having set out three ways of crediting a settlement against the defendants who go to trial, the Court explained which of them are pro tanto rules. The defendants in the case had asked for a pro tanto credit.
Under the pro tanto rule, the nonsettling defendant would be liable for 75% of the damages ($750,000, which is $1 million minus $250,000). The litigating defendant is thus responsible for far more than its proportionate share of the damages.
In a footnote, the Court supposed a plaintiff who sues two equally responsible defendants, settles with one for $250,000, and proves $1 million in damages against the other at trial.
By disadvantaging the party that spurns settlement offers, the pro tanto rule puts pressure on all defendants to settle. . . . While public policy wisely encourages settlements, such additional pressure to settle is unnecessary.
Weighing the two approaches, the Court granted that the pro tanto rule encourages settlement, then explained why that advantage did not carry the day.
Where it appears in the rules
The rule pages below use the phrase in their official text: an Alabama venue rule that refers to a pro tanto settlement, two Georgia provisions on execution liens and bonds (one uses the phrase only in its title), and a Connecticut rule on the transfer of a claimant’s rights to a client security fund.
4 rule pages in 3 jurisdictions use “pro tanto” in their official text.
Some rulesets state the pro tanto settlement credit without the Latin. California’s Code of Civil Procedure § 877(a) says a good-faith settlement with one tortfeasor shall “reduce the claims against the others in the amount stipulated by the release, the dismissal or the covenant, or in the amount of the consideration paid for it, whichever is the greater”, and Oklahoma’s 12 O.S. § 832(H) uses nearly the same words: it “reduces the claim against others to the extent of any amount stipulated by the release or the covenant, or in the amount of the consideration paid for it, whichever is greater”.
Frequently asked questions
What does pro tanto mean?
“To that extent,” or “for so much.” Something done pro tanto takes effect only as far as a stated amount reaches. A payment that satisfies a debt pro tanto pays it off to the extent of the payment, and the rest remains owing.
What is a pro tanto settlement credit?
When one of several defendants settles, a pro tanto credit reduces the judgment against the others by the dollar amount the settling defendant paid. If the plaintiff settles with one defendant for $100,000 and later wins $500,000 against another, a pro tanto credit leaves $400,000 owing, whatever the settling defendant’s share of fault.
How is a pro tanto credit different from the proportionate-share approach?
A pro tanto credit subtracts the settlement amount. The proportionate-share approach subtracts the settling defendant’s share of fault, as found at trial. If that defendant was 50% at fault, the plaintiff can collect no more than the other 50% from those who went to trial, however much or little the settlement was. The Supreme Court adopted the proportionate-share approach for federal admiralty cases in McDermott, Inc. v. AmClyde (1994).
Is the pro tanto rule fair to the defendant who goes to trial?
It can cut either way. If the other defendant settled cheaply, the defendant who went to trial may pay more than its share of fault; if the settlement was generous, it may pay less. Many jurisdictions that use a pro tanto credit guard against collusive or bargain settlements by requiring that the settlement be made in good faith, sometimes with a court hearing on the question.
Is pro tanto the same as pro rata?
No. Pro rata means in proportion: a fund divided pro rata is split by shares or percentages. Pro tanto means to the extent of a fixed amount. A pro rata reduction depends on shares; a pro tanto reduction depends on dollars. Be careful with “pro rata” in settlement cases, though: it is used loosely, sometimes for the proportionate-share approach and sometimes for an equal split among defendants, which is why the Supreme Court avoided the term in McDermott.