Non Sequitur
nōn sĕquĭtur · also written a classic non sequitur
Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 13, 2026
Pronunciation
There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most Americans say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.
- Common US pronunciation: non SEK-wih-tur, IPA /ˌnɑːn ˈsɛkwɪtər/. Some say nohn, /ˌnoʊn/, for the first word.
- Classical Latin (restored): NOHN SEH-kwih-tur, IPA [noːn ˈsɛkʷɪtʊr]. The ō of nōn was long, the u of -tur short, as in put, and the stress falls on the first syllable of sequitur.
Literal translation
- non — not
- sequitur — it follows; a form of sequor, “to follow”
Put together: “it does not follow.”
What it means in law
A non sequitur is a conclusion that does not follow from its premises. The premises may be true, and the conclusion may even be true, but the one does not lead to the other. The phrase is not a legal doctrine. It is a term of logic that judges borrow, usually in a single sentence, to say that an argument has a missing step. The opinions quoted on this page use the phrase without stopping to define it, so they show its meaning by example.
A judge who calls an argument a non sequitur usually names the premise, names the conclusion and then shows the gap. Four examples from the Supreme Court show the pattern.
Personal jurisdiction. In Hanson v. Denckla (1958) a woman had set up a trust with a Delaware trustee and later moved to Florida, where she died. Florida’s courts were then asked to rule on the trust. The argument was that because she and most of the people interested in the trust lived in Florida, Florida’s courts could exercise jurisdiction over the Delaware trustee. The Court called that a non sequitur. Other people’s ties to Florida said nothing about the trustee’s own acts there, and jurisdiction over a defendant depends on what that defendant did.
Sovereignty. In Gamble v. United States (2019) the Court reaffirmed that the federal government and a State are separate sovereigns, so each may prosecute the same conduct without violating the Double Jeopardy Clause. The dissents argued that sovereignty belongs to the people, not to governments. The Court agreed with the premise but not the conclusion: the people are sovereign, but it does not follow that they gave all the powers of sovereignty to a single government.
In dissents. Dissenting Justices use the phrase too. Chief Justice Taft, dissenting in Adkins v. Children’s Hospital (1923), rejected the argument that a power to set a minimum wage must also include a power to set a maximum wage, because law draws such lines by degree and experience, not pure logic. Justice Stevens, dissenting in Payne v. Tennessee (1991), called it a non sequitur to reason that because a defendant may offer evidence of his own character at sentencing, the State should be able to answer with evidence about the victim’s character. The victim, he wrote, is not on trial. In both cases the majority took the other view, so these passages show how the phrase is used, not what the law is.
The phrase is close kin to other terms of argument. Post hoc ergo propter hoc names one particular non sequitur, the assumption that because one event followed another, the first caused the second. Ipse dixit describes a conclusion supported only by someone’s say-so. An a fortiori argument runs the other way: it claims that a conclusion follows even more strongly than in a case already accepted.
Etymology
Non is the ordinary Latin “not.” Lewis & Short explain it as a contraction of an older form, which they analyze as nec unum, “not one”. Sequitur is the third person singular present of sequor, which the dictionary glosses “to follow, to come or go after, to follow after, attend.” Latin gives sequor a passive form with an active meaning, so sequitur means “it follows”; that grammatical reading is ours. The saved entries do not record non sequitur as a phrase.
Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries nōn, sĕquor, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.
In the opinions
Four passages quoted from the official United States Reports. None defines the phrase; each shows it at work. Two are from opinions of the Court and two are from dissents, which are labelled. A spaced ellipsis marks where a citation or a footnote number has been left out. The Gamble passage comes from the bound volume the Supreme Court publishes on its own website, since that volume is not yet on GovInfo.
It is urged that because the settlor and most of the appointees and beneficiaries were domiciled in Florida the courts of that State should be able to exercise personal jurisdiction over the nonresident trustees. This is a non sequitur. With personal jurisdiction over the executor, legatees, and appointees, there is nothing in federal law to prevent Florida from adjudicating concerning the respective rights and liabilities of those parties. But Florida has not chosen to do so. As we understand its law, the trustee is an indispensable party over whom the court must acquire jurisdiction before it is empowered to enter judgment in a proceeding affecting the validity of a trust. . . . It does not acquire that jurisdiction by being the “center of gravity” of the controversy, or the most convenient location for litigation. The issue is personal jurisdiction, not choice of law. It is resolved in this case by considering the acts of the trustee.
The question was whether Florida’s courts had jurisdiction over a Delaware trustee. The Court had just held that the trustee’s own contacts with Florida were not enough.
First, the dissents contend that our dual-sovereignty rule errs in treating the Federal and State Governments as two separate sovereigns when in fact sovereignty belongs to the people. . . . This argument is based on a non sequitur. Yes, our Constitution rests on the principle that the people are sovereign, but that does not mean that they have conferred all the attributes of sovereignty on a single government.
Reaffirming that the federal government and a State are separate sovereigns for double jeopardy purposes, the Court answered the dissents’ argument that sovereignty belongs to the people. The omitted words are citations to the two dissents.
This, I submit, is a non sequitur. A line of distinction like the one under discussion in this case is, as the opinion elsewhere admits, a matter of degree and practical experience and not of pure logic. Certainly the wide difference between prescribing a minimum wage and a maximum wage could as a matter of degree and experience be easily affirmed.
Dissenting, in an opinion Justice Sanford joined, Chief Justice Taft answered the majority’s view that a power to fix a minimum wage would carry with it a power to fix a maximum wage. The Court later overruled Adkins.
Because our decision in Lockett, 438 U. S., at 604 (opinion of Burger, C. J.), recognizes the defendant’s right to introduce all mitigating evidence that may inform the jury about his character, the Court suggests that fairness requires that the State be allowed to respond with similar evidence about the victim. . . . This argument is a classic non sequitur: The victim is not on trial; her character, whether good or bad, cannot therefore constitute either an aggravating or a mitigating circumstance.
Dissenting, joined by Justice Blackmun, from the decision allowing victim impact evidence at a capital sentencing hearing.
Where it appears in the rules
No rule on this site uses “non sequitur” in its official text.
That is to be expected: the phrase describes a flaw in reasoning, not a procedure, so it belongs in briefs and opinions rather than in court rules.
Frequently asked questions
What does non sequitur mean in law?
The same thing it means anywhere: a conclusion that does not follow from the reasons given. Judges use it to reject an argument whose logic has a gap, usually by naming the premise and showing why the conclusion does not follow.
Is a non sequitur a legal doctrine?
No. It is a term of logic. No rule of court is built on it. It labels a weakness in an argument, and the case is still decided under whatever law governs it.
Can you give an example of a non sequitur from a court case?
In Hanson v. Denckla (1958) it was argued that because a trust’s creator and most of its beneficiaries lived in Florida, Florida’s courts had jurisdiction over the out-of-state trustee. The Supreme Court called that a non sequitur: jurisdiction over a defendant depends on the defendant’s own acts, not on where other people live.
Is a non sequitur the same as post hoc ergo propter hoc?
Post hoc ergo propter hoc is one kind of non sequitur. It wrongly concludes that because one event came after another, the first caused the second. A non sequitur is the broader idea of any conclusion that does not follow.
Does calling an argument a non sequitur end the case?
Not by itself. It is a way of explaining why an argument fails. Dissenting Justices have called the majority’s reasoning a non sequitur, and the majority’s view still decided the case.