A Fortiori
ā fortiōrī
Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 13, 2026
Pronunciation
There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.
- Common US legal pronunciation: ah for-shee-OR-ee, IPA /ˌɑː fɔːrʃiˈɔːri/. Many lawyers say ay for-tee-OR-eye, /ˌeɪ fɔːrtiˈɔːraɪ/, and mixtures of the two are common; all are heard in court.
- Classical Latin (restored): ah for-tee-OH-ree, IPA [aː fɔrtiˈoːriː]. The t stays hard, and the stress falls on the long ō of fortiōrī.
Literal translation
- a — from; a form of the preposition ab
- fortiori — stronger; the form of fortior, “stronger,” that follows a
Put together: “from the stronger,” with the word for “reason” or “argument” left unsaid. In plain English: “all the more so.”
What it means in law
An a fortiori argument runs from a weaker case to a stronger one. If a rule applies where the reasons for it are thin, it applies with greater force where those reasons are strong. If a speed limit forbids driving at 40 miles an hour, then a fortiori it forbids driving at 60. The phrase announces that step.
Courts use the words in three ways. They open a sentence with them (“A fortiori, …”). They set them inside a clause (“the claim must fail, a fortiori”). And they use them as an adjective, calling a dispute “an a fortiori case” when it is a stronger version of one already decided. All three appear in the passages below.
The phrase is a tool of reasoning, not a doctrine. It has no elements and no test, and a court is never bound to accept an argument because it carries the label. The argument is only as good as the comparison behind it. It works when the two cases differ in degree: more harm, less excuse, a clearer violation of the same rule. It fails when they differ in kind, so that the reasons behind the first rule do not apply to the second case at all.
The Supreme Court made that point in Cheney v. United States District Court (2004). The Vice President and the other officials on his energy task force had been sued in a civil case seeking the task force’s records. The court of appeals reasoned that because United States v. Nixon (1974) refused a President’s broad claim of confidentiality even though he had invoked executive privilege, it must, a fortiori, have defeated these officials’ claim of immunity from discovery, where no privilege had been invoked at all. The Supreme Court disagreed. Among other differences, Nixon was a criminal case about evidence needed for a trial, while Cheney was a civil case about discovery, and Nixon’s subpoenas were narrow where these discovery requests were broad. The two were not points on one scale, so the step from one to the other did not hold.
Lawyers meet the phrase most often in briefs and opinions about precedent. A party argues that an earlier decision controls a new case not because the facts match, but because the new facts make the earlier reasoning even stronger. A court asked to accept that argument will generally look hard at whether the earlier case turned on the feature the new case has more of, or on something the new case lacks.
The phrase should not be confused with arguendo, which marks a point assumed only for the sake of argument. An a fortiori argument asserts that the conclusion follows; an assumption made arguendo leaves the point undecided.
Etymology
A is a form of the Latin preposition ab, which Lewis & Short gloss, in its figurative sense, as “from, away from, out of . . .”. Fortiori comes from the adjective fortis, which the dictionary glosses first as “strong, powerful.” Fortior is its comparative, “stronger,” and fortiōrī is the form that comparative takes after ab; that grammatical reading is ours, not the dictionary’s.
Neither saved entry records a fortiori as a phrase, and no saved opinion gives a fuller Latin form. We read the unstated noun as “reason” or “argument,” so that the phrase means “from a stronger reason”; that reading too is ours. It matches how courts use the words: the conclusion is drawn from a case where the grounds for it are stronger still.
Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries ăb, ā, fortis, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.
In the opinions
Three Supreme Court passages that show the reasoning at work, including one in which the Court rejected an a fortiori argument. Each is quoted from the official United States Reports; a spaced ellipsis marks where a citation has been left out.
Although the challenged statutory language at issue in City of Mesquite had been eliminated while the case was pending in the Court of Appeals, we held that the case was not moot, because the defendant’s “repeal of the objectionable language would not preclude it from reenacting precisely the same provision if the District Court’s judgment were vacated.” . . . This is an a fortiori case. There is no mere risk that Jacksonville will repeat its allegedly wrongful conduct; it has already done so.
Jacksonville repealed the contracting ordinance a group of contractors had challenged and passed a similar one, then argued that the case was moot. The Court compared it with a 1982 decision about a repealed provision that a city remained free to re-enact; the inner quotation is from that decision.
As Mr. Justice Holmes explained in Moore v. Dempsey, see pp. 421-422, supra, a mob-dominated trial is no less a denial of due process because the State Supreme Court believed that the trial was actually a fair one. A fortiori, due process denied in the proceedings leading to conviction is not restored just because the state court declines to adjudicate the claimed denial on the merits.
One argument against the Court’s conclusion was that a prisoner who lost a federal claim under a state procedural rule had received all the process he was due. The Court answered with an a fortiori step. The case’s rule on claims a prisoner failed to raise in state court was later abandoned in Coleman v. Thompson (1991); the passage is quoted for its reasoning.
If Nixon refused to recognize broad claims of confidentiality where the President had asserted executive privilege, the majority reasoned, Nixon must have rejected, a fortiori, petitioners’ claim of discovery immunity where the privilege has not even been invoked. According to the majority, because the Executive Branch can invoke executive privilege to maintain the separation of powers, mandamus relief is premature. This analysis, however, overlooks fundamental differences in the two cases. Nixon cannot bear the weight the Court of Appeals puts upon it.
The court of appeals had reasoned from United States v. Nixon (1974) to the claim of the Vice President and his task force colleagues, the petitioners, to immunity from civil discovery. The Court described that reasoning and then refused it.
Where it appears in the rules
No rule on this site uses “a fortiori” in its official text.
That is what you would expect of a word that describes a step in reasoning. Rules of procedure state requirements; the phrase belongs to the arguments lawyers and judges make about them.
Frequently asked questions
What does a fortiori mean in plain English?
It means “all the more so” or “with even stronger reason.” A speaker who says a fortiori is claiming that a conclusion already accepted for one case applies with greater force to another, because the second case has more of whatever made the first conclusion right.
How is a fortiori used in a sentence?
Usually at the start of a sentence that follows a point already made: “The court refused to extend the deadline for a party who had a good excuse. A fortiori, it will not extend it for a party who has none.” It can also sit inside a clause (“the claim fails a fortiori”) or describe a whole case (“this is an a fortiori case”).
Is an a fortiori argument always valid?
No. It holds only when the two cases differ in degree on the point that matters. If they differ in kind, the reasons behind the first conclusion may not reach the second at all. In Cheney v. United States District Court (2004) the Supreme Court rejected an a fortiori argument because, among other differences, the earlier case was a criminal one and the new case was civil.
Is a fortiori a legal doctrine?
No. It is a form of reasoning that lawyers and judges use in every field of law. It has no elements, and calling an argument a fortiori does not make it binding on a court. What matters is whether the comparison behind it is sound.
How is a fortiori different from arguendo?
An a fortiori argument says a conclusion follows, with more force, from what has already been shown. Arguendo marks a premise accepted only for the sake of argument, which the court does not decide. The first asserts; the second assumes.