Ex Turpi Causa
ex turpī causā nōn ŏrĭtur actĭo · also written ex turpi causa non oritur actio
Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 13, 2026
Pronunciation
There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers say the maxim, and how a Roman would have said it.
- Common US legal pronunciation: eks TER-pee KAW-zuh non OR-ih-ter AK-shee-oh, IPA /ɛks ˈtɝpi ˈkɔːzə nɑn ˈɔːrɪtər ˈækʃioʊ/. Some say TER-pye, /ˈtɝpaɪ/, and KOW-zuh, /ˈkaʊzə/.
- Classical Latin (restored): eks TUR-pee KOW-sah nohn OR-ih-tur AHK-tee-oh, IPA [ɛks ˈtʊrpiː ˈkau̯saː noːn ˈɔrɪtʊr ˈaktɪoː]. The u of turpi and of -tur is short, as in put; the first o of oritur is short, as in off; and the s of causa was never voiced as a z.
Literal translation
- ex — out of, from
- turpi — shameful, base; a form of turpis
- causa — a cause, a ground; the word also meant a lawsuit
- non oritur — does not arise
- actio — an action, a lawsuit
Put together: “from a shameful cause no action arises.” The short form, ex turpi causa, is “from a shameful cause.”
What it means in law
The maxim states an old rule of the common law: a court will not lend its help to someone whose claim rests on an illegal or immoral bargain. If a plaintiff must prove the illegal agreement to win, the court will not enforce it, and it will not enforce rights that spring directly from it. Outside contract law, some courts apply the same idea, sometimes under the same Latin name, to bar tort claims that arise from the plaintiff’s own serious wrongdoing.
The Supreme Court’s leading statement of the rule is McMullen v. Hoffman (1899), and it is the one opinion of that Court found for this page that uses the Latin. Two contractors bid for the work of building a water pipeline for the city of Portland, Oregon. They had secretly agreed to share the work, and they put in bids that looked like competing offers but were not. After they won the contract they signed a written partnership agreement, and McMullen later sued Hoffman for his share of the profits under it. The Court held that the partnership writing was only part of one illegal agreement and could not be separated from the secret bid-rigging. It refused relief. As the Court put it at the end, the law would leave the parties as it found them.
McMullen named three old maxims that, it said, mean substantially the same thing: ex dolo malo non oritur actio (no action arises from fraud), ex pacto illicito non oritur actio (no action arises from an unlawful agreement) and ex turpi causa non oritur actio. The translations are ours.
The rule can look unfair, since it may let a wrongdoer keep what he received. The Court faced that directly. The defense is allowed, it said, not for the defendant’s sake but for the public’s. Parties who know that courts will not enforce their illegal bargains are less likely to make them.
The rule has limits, and the Court in McMullen reviewed cases said to fall outside it. One line of cases lets a plaintiff recover money that an agent or partner received on the plaintiff’s behalf, when the plaintiff can recover without relying on the illegal contract. The Court found that no such exception fit the case before it. Where the line falls today depends on the jurisdiction and on the law that was broken.
The maxim sits close to in pari delicto, the defense that a plaintiff equally at fault cannot recover. McMullen tied them together: in cases of this kind, it said, the defendant’s position is the stronger. Ex turpi causa looks at where the claim comes from; in pari delicto compares the parties’ fault. Courts often apply the two together.
Etymology
Ex is the Latin preposition “out of, from”. Turpī is a form of turpis, whose first, physical sense Lewis & Short give as “ugly, unsightly, unseemly, foul, filthy” and whose moral sense is “unseemly, shameful, disgraceful, base, infamous, scandalous, dishonorable”. The maxim uses the moral sense.
Causā is a form of causa, “a cause, reason, motive, inducement”, which in legal Latin also meant “a cause, judicial process, lawsuit”. Nōn is “not”. Ŏrĭtur is from the verb ŏrĭor, which the dictionary glosses in one sense as “arise, proceed, originate”. Actĭo, in legal language, is “An action, suit, process”.
The dictionary does not record the maxim. Reading causa here as the ground of a claim, rather than a lawsuit, is ours.
Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries ex, turpis, causa, nōn, ŏrĭor, actĭo, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.
In the opinions
Three passages from McMullen v. Hoffman (1899), the one Supreme Court opinion found that uses the Latin maxim, quoted from the official United States Reports. The sentence in which the Court lists the three maxims is not quoted, because the official text’s reading of it is damaged; the maxims are named in the explanation above.
There are several old and very familiar maxims of the common law which formulate the result of that law in regard to illegal contracts. They are cited in all law books upon the subject and are known to all of us. They mean substantially the same thing and are founded upon the same principles and reasoning.
Having held the contractors’ whole arrangement illegal, the Court turned to its consequences. The next sentence names the three maxims, ex turpi causa among them.
The authorities from the earliest time to the present unanimously hold that no court will lend its assistance in any way towards carrying out the terms of an illegal contract. In case any action is brought in which it is necessary to prove the illegal contract in order to maintain the action, courts will not enforce it, nor will they enforce any alleged rights directly springing from such contract. In cases of this kind the maxim is Potior est conditio defendentis.
A few sentences later on the same page, after an account of an English case about two highwaymen, the Court stated the rule and the related maxim that the defendant’s position is the stronger.
The court refuses to enforce such a contract and it permits defendant to set up its illegality, not out of any regard for the defendant who sets it up, but only on account of the public interest. It has been often stated in similar cases that the defence is a very dishonest one, and it lies ill in the mouth of the defendant to allege it, and it is only allowed for public considerations and in order the better to secure the public against dishonest transactions.
After surveying cases said to be exceptions and finding none that fit, the Court explained why it lets a defendant raise the illegality of his own bargain.
Where it appears in the rules
No rule on this site uses “ex turpi causa” in its official text.
The rules state the defense in English. Federal Rule 8(c)(1) lists “illegality” among the affirmative defenses a party must state in its responsive pleading, and many states’ versions of Rule 8(c) list it too, among them Arizona’s and Montana’s.
Frequently asked questions
What does ex turpi causa non oritur actio mean?
“No action arises from a shameful cause.” A court will not help a party enforce an illegal or immoral agreement, or any claim that can be proved only by proving such an agreement.
How is ex turpi causa different from in pari delicto?
They are closely related and often appear together. Ex turpi causa asks whether the claim grows out of an illegal or immoral act. In pari delicto asks whether the plaintiff is at least as much at fault as the defendant, and if so leaves the loss where it lies. In McMullen v. Hoffman (1899) the Supreme Court stated the illegal-contract rule and then added the related maxim that, in such cases, the defendant’s position is the stronger.
Can a party ever recover money connected with an illegal contract?
Sometimes. In McMullen the Supreme Court discussed cases allowing a plaintiff to recover money that someone else received for him, where he did not have to rely on the illegal contract to get it back, though it found none of them fit the case before it. How far such exceptions reach today depends on the jurisdiction and on the law involved.
Why does the law let the wrongdoing defendant keep the benefit?
Because the rule is aimed at the public good, not at fairness between the two parties. The Supreme Court admitted that the defense lies ill in the defendant’s mouth, but it said that refusing help to both sides of an illegal bargain discourages such bargains.
Does a defendant have to raise illegality?
Generally, yes. Illegality is listed as an affirmative defense in Federal Rule 8(c)(1), so it belongs in the defendant’s answer, and a defendant who leaves it out risks losing it. Many states’ rules list it the same way. Because the bar exists for the public’s sake, as McMullen explained, courts may still refuse on their own to enforce a contract that is plainly illegal, even when no one has pleaded the defense.