RulesofCivilProcedure.com Civil Procedure · Every State

Coram Non Judice

cōram nōn jūdĭce

Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 16, 2026

Quick answerCoram non judice, “not before a judge,” describes a proceeding held by a court that had no lawful authority over the case or the person, so that its judgment is void rather than merely mistaken.

Pronunciation

There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers and judges say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.

  • Common US legal pronunciation: KOR-um non JOO-dih-see, IPA /ˈkɔːrəm nɑːn ˈdʒuːdɪsi/. Some say KOR-um nohn YOO-dih-kay, /ˈkɔːrəm noʊn ˈjuːdɪkeɪ/, closer to the Latin.
  • Classical Latin (restored): KOH-rahm nohn YOO-dih-keh, IPA [ˈkoːram noːn ˈjuːdɪkɛ]. The o of cōram and of nōn and the u of jūdice were long; the i was short, so judice is stressed on its first syllable.

Literal translation

  • coram — in the presence of, before
  • non — not
  • judice — a judge; the ablative of judex, the case coram takes

Put together: “not before a judge.” A plurality of the Supreme Court has rendered it as before a person not a judge (quoted below). In law it describes a proceeding that was not truly judicial because the court had no lawful power to hold it.

What it means in law

A court can make two very different kinds of mistake. It can decide a case it has power to decide, and decide it wrongly. Or it can act when it has no power to act at all. The first kind of judgment is erroneous: it binds the parties until it is reversed on appeal or set aside. The second kind is void. Coram non judice is the old name for the second kind. A proceeding held by a court without jurisdiction is treated as if it had happened before someone who was not a judge, so it cannot produce a judgment.

The idea is old. A plurality of the Supreme Court traced it, in Burnham v. Superior Court (1990), to the English Year Books of the fifteenth century and to Lord Coke in the early seventeenth, and noted that American courts refused to honor judgments that broke the principle well before the Fourteenth Amendment.

The classic case is a court that lacks power over the defendant. In Pennoyer v. Neff (1878) an Oregon court had entered a money judgment against a man who did not live in Oregon, was never personally served in Oregon (notice of the suit was only published in a newspaper) and never appeared. The Supreme Court held that a personal judgment entered that way is void, and that it has no force even in the State whose court entered it. Pennoyer also tied the rule to the Constitution: a judgment entered without jurisdiction over the person violates the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The test for when a court has that power has changed a great deal since 1878, but the consequence of lacking it has not. A judgment entered without it is void.

Courts use the same label for other gaps in a court’s power. The point is always the same: the defect is in the court’s authority, not in its reasoning.

The difference matters in practice. A void judgment can usually be attacked even after the time for appeal has passed, and other courts need not enforce it. Federal Rule 60(b)(4) lets a court relieve a party from a final judgment when “the judgment is void”, and most states have similar rules. But a defendant who appears and loses a challenge to jurisdiction is generally bound by that ruling, and a party who waits may face other limits, so a claim that a judgment is coram non judice is not a way around every deadline.

Etymology

Cōram is a preposition and adverb that Lewis & Short glosses “in the presence of, before the eyes of, in the face of, before”. As a preposition it takes the ablative, and among its examples is coram judicibus (Suet. Aug. 56), before the judges.

Nōn is “not”. Jūdice is the ablative of jūdex, “a judge”, a word the dictionary derives from jūs, right or law, and the verb dīco, to say ([jus-, 2. dico]).

Lewis & Short does not record the phrase coram non judice. Reading it as “before one who is not a judge” is ours, and it matches the rendering in the Burnham plurality opinion quoted below.

Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries cōram, nōn, jūdex, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.

In the opinions

Two Supreme Court passages, newest first. Each is quoted from the official United States Reports; a spaced ellipsis marks where a citation has been left out.

Traditionally that proposition was embodied in the phrase coram non judice, “before a person not a judge” -meaning, in effect, that the proceeding in question was not a judicial proceeding because lawful judicial authority was not present, and could therefore not yield a judgment. American courts invalidated, or denied recognition to, judgments that violated this common-law principle long before the Fourteenth Amendment was adopted. . . . In Pennoyer v. Neff, 95 U. S. 714, 732 (1878), we announced that the judgment of a court lacking personal jurisdiction violated the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment as well.

Burnham v. Superior Court of Cal., 495 U.S. 604, 608–609 (1990) · Supreme Court of the United States · Justice Scalia, plurality opinion

A New Jersey man was served with divorce papers while briefly visiting California. Before upholding the California court’s jurisdiction, Justice Scalia, writing in this part for four Justices, traced the rule that a judgment of a court lacking jurisdiction is void. That rule is the proposition the passage refers to. The bound volume prints a dash after “judge”; the text of the official online copy has a hyphen there, and the quotation follows that text.

In several of the cases, the decision has been accompanied with the observation that a personal judgment thus recovered has no binding force without the State in which it is rendered, implying that in such State it may be valid and binding. But if the court has no jurisdiction over the person of the defendant by reason of his nonresidence, and, consequently, no authority to pass upon his personal rights and obligations; if the whole proceeding, without service upon him or his appearance, is coram non judice and void; if to hold a defendant bound by such a judgment is contrary to the first principles of justice, — it is difficult to see how the judgment can legitimately have any force within the State.

Pennoyer v. Neff, 95 U.S. 714, 732 (1878) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice Field

Some earlier decisions had said that a personal judgment against a nonresident who was never served had no force outside the State that entered it. Justice Field rejected the suggestion that it could be valid inside that State.

Where it appears in the rules

No rule on this site uses “coram non judice” in its official text.

Rules of procedure state the consequence in plain English instead. Federal Rule 60(b)(4), for example, allows relief from a final judgment when “the judgment is void”, and many states’ versions of Rule 60 use the same words.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between a void judgment and an erroneous one?

An erroneous judgment comes from a court that had power to decide the case but decided it wrongly; it stands until it is reversed on appeal or set aside. A void judgment comes from a court that had no power to act at all, and the law treats it as having no effect. Coram non judice is the old name for the second kind.

What makes a proceeding coram non judice?

The court’s lack of authority, not a mistake in its reasoning. The classic example is a personal judgment against a defendant over whom the court had no jurisdiction, such as a nonresident who was never properly served and never appeared, as in Pennoyer v. Neff (1878).

Can a void judgment be challenged after the time to appeal has run?

Often, yes. Federal Rule 60(b)(4) allows a motion for relief from a void judgment, and Rule 60(c)(1) requires only that it be made “within a reasonable time”; the one-year limit applies only to grounds (1) through (3), such as mistake and fraud. Many courts go further and treat a void judgment as open to attack at any time. But a party who appeared and lost a challenge to jurisdiction is usually bound by that ruling, and some courts apply other limits, so the answer depends on the circumstances and the court.

Is coram non judice the same as coram nobis?

No. Coram nobis, “before us,” is the name of an old writ asking a court to correct its own judgment because of an error of fact. Coram non judice is not a writ at all; it describes a proceeding held without judicial authority. The two share only the word coram.

This page explains a legal term. It is legal information, not legal advice, and it cannot tell you how the law applies to your situation. Whether a judgment can be attacked as void, and how and when, depends on the court that entered it and on the rules of the court where it is challenged. If the outcome matters, talk to a lawyer or your court’s self-help center.