Coram Nobis
cōram nōbīs · also written writ of error coram nobis
Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 13, 2026
Pronunciation
There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.
- Common US legal pronunciation: KOR-um NOH-bis, IPA /ˌkɔːrəm ˈnoʊbɪs/.
- Classical Latin (restored): KOH-rahm NOH-bees, IPA [ˈkoːram ˈnoːbiːs]. Both vowels of nōbīs are long.
Literal translation
- coram — before, in the presence of
- nobis — us; a form of nos, “we”
Put together: “before us,” meaning before the court that gave the judgment, not a higher one.
What it means in law
Most ways of attacking a judgment send the case up: an appeal goes to a higher court. Coram nobis goes back to the court that decided the case. It asks that court to set aside its own final judgment because of an error serious enough to make the judgment unjust, an error that did not appear in the record and could not be raised on appeal.
At common law the writ corrected errors of fact that the court had not known about when it ruled. Over time, in American criminal law, it grew. In United States v. Morgan (1954) the Supreme Court held that federal courts may grant it under the All Writs Act to a person who has already finished a federal sentence and so can no longer use the post-conviction remedy for prisoners in custody, but who still suffers from the conviction. Morgan said he had been convicted without a lawyer, and his federal conviction had led to a longer state sentence as a repeat offender. The Court allowed his claim to go forward.
The writ is reserved for rare cases. Morgan limited it to circumstances compelling relief to achieve justice, and United States v. Denedo (2009) repeated that it reaches fundamental errors, not technical ones, and is unavailable when another remedy, such as habeas corpus, would do. Denedo held that military appellate courts, too, may hear such petitions about their own earlier judgments.
In federal civil cases the writ is gone. Federal Rule 60(e) says that “writs of coram nobis, coram vobis, and audita querela” are among the remedies abolished, and many states’ rules or statutes say much the same: the list below includes such provisions from 25 of the 49 states on this site and from the District of Columbia. Where a state’s rules do not abolish the writ, whether some narrow civil form of it survives is a question of that state’s law. In federal court, a party who wants relief from a civil judgment instead files a motion under Rule 60(b) or, in rare cases, an independent action. Some rulesets draw the line expressly: Arkansas abolishes the writ in civil cases, which leaves its criminal use to other law, and Virginia’s discovery rules still provide for proceedings in the nature of coram nobis.
Coram nobis should be kept apart from habeas corpus, which challenges present custody and is brought as a separate civil case. Morgan described the federal request for coram nobis as a motion that is a step in the criminal case itself. Its companion writ, coram vobis, usually appears beside it in the rules that abolish both.
Etymology
Cōram is a Latin preposition and adverb meaning “in the presence of, before the eyes of, in the face of, before”. Nōbīs is a form of nos, which Lewis & Short gloss “we”, and which it treats as the plural of ego, “I.” After coram, nobis means “us.”
The dictionary does not record the phrase or say who the “us” was. We read it as the court that gave the judgment, since that is the court the writ is addressed to; that reading is ours. The modern Supreme Court says only that the writ traces its origins to the English courts of King’s Bench and Common Pleas.
Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries cōram, nōs, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.
In the opinions
Three passages from United States v. Denedo (2009), the Supreme Court’s most recent account of the writ, which restates the 1954 Morgan decision. Morgan itself is printed in an older official volume whose scanned text this site’s checking tools cannot reliably read, so it is described above rather than quoted. Each passage is quoted from the official United States Reports; a spaced ellipsis marks where a citation has been left out.
The writ of coram nobis is an ancient common-law remedy designed “to correct errors of fact.”
A former sailor whose guilty plea in a court-martial had led to deportation proceedings asked the military appeals court that had affirmed his conviction to set it aside. Explaining the writ, the Court quoted United States v. Morgan (1954).
Any rationale confining the writ to technical errors, however, has been superseded; for in its modern iteration coram nobis is broader than its common-law predecessor. This is confirmed by our opinion in Morgan. In that case we found that a writ of coram nobis can issue to redress a fundamental error, there a deprivation of counsel in violation of the Sixth Amendment, as opposed to mere technical errors.
The Court had just described the writ’s narrow use in English practice, for technical errors. That case in the passage is Morgan.
To confine the use of coram nobis so that finality is not at risk in a great number of cases, we were careful in Morgan to limit the availability of the writ to “extraordinary” cases presenting circumstances compelling its use “to achieve justice.” . . . Another limit, of course, is that an extraordinary remedy may not issue when alternative remedies, such as habeas corpus, are available.
Continuing the same discussion, the Court restated the limits it had set in Morgan; the inner quotations are Morgan’s words.
Where it appears in the rules
Most of the rule pages below are a jurisdiction’s version of Rule 60, which abolishes the writ in civil cases and channels relief from judgments into a motion or an independent action. Illinois does the same in its statute on relief from final judgments, and Mississippi in its rule on special proceedings. Virginia’s rules on the scope of discovery use the phrase for proceedings that still exist there. Each link opens the rule with its full verbatim text.
30 rule pages in 28 jurisdictions use “coram nobis” in their official text.
District of Columbia 1
Kentucky 1
Mississippi 2
New Mexico 1
North Dakota 1
South Carolina 1
West Virginia 1
Two more rulesets name only the companion writ. Michigan’s MCR 2.612(C) provides that relief from a judgment “may not be sought or obtained by the writs of coram vobis, audita querela, bills of review, or bills in the nature of a bill of review”. And Virginia Code § 8.01-677 lets a court correct on motion, after reasonable notice, any clerical error or error in fact “for which a judgment may be reversed or corrected on writ of error coram vobis”.
Frequently asked questions
What is a writ of coram nobis?
A request to the court that entered a judgment to set it aside because of a fundamental error that was not in the record, usually made after the case is over and no appeal is left. Today it is used mainly to challenge criminal convictions.
Who can use coram nobis?
In federal court, generally a person who is no longer in custody on the conviction, so habeas corpus and the post-conviction motion for prisoners are unavailable, but who still suffers serious consequences from it. The person must show a fundamental error and compelling reasons why justice requires relief. State rules differ, and some states have their own statutory remedies.
Is coram nobis available in civil cases?
Not in federal court, and not in the many states whose rules abolish it. Federal Rule 60(e) abolishes it, along with several other old writs, and so do the rules or statutes of many states. In those courts, relief from a civil judgment comes instead by a motion under Rule 60(b) or its state counterpart or, rarely, an independent action. Where a state has not abolished the writ, its own law decides what is left of it.
What is the difference between coram nobis and habeas corpus?
Habeas corpus challenges present custody: it asks why a person is being held. Coram nobis can be used after custody has ended, to attack the conviction itself because of its continuing effects. If habeas corpus or another remedy is available, coram nobis generally is not.
Is coram nobis the same as an appeal?
No. An appeal asks a higher court to review errors in the record. Coram nobis asks the same court that gave the judgment to correct an error outside the record, after the time for ordinary review has passed.