Forum Non Conveniens
fŏrum nōn convĕnĭens · also written inconvenient forum (the English form used in some rules)
Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 12, 2026
Pronunciation
There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers and judges say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.
- Common US legal pronunciation: FOR-um non kun-VEE-nee-enz, IPA /ˈfɔːrəm nɑːn kənˈviːniənz/. Some lawyers say nohn for the middle word and kon-VAY-nee-enz for the last; all are heard in court.
- Classical Latin (restored): FOR-oom nohn kon-WEH-nee-ens, IPA [ˈfɔrʊm noːn kɔnˈwɛnɪeːns]. Latin V was pronounced like an English W.
Literal translation
- forum — a public square or marketplace, where Roman courts sat; here, a court
- non — not
- conveniens — fitting, suitable; the present participle of convĕnĭō, to come together or to suit
Put together: “a forum that is not suitable,” or simply “an inconvenient court.”
What it means in law
Forum non conveniens lets a court that has the power to hear a case decline to hear it because another available court is far better placed to do so. It does not deny that the court could hear the case. It asks whether, all things considered, the case belongs somewhere else.
The doctrine presupposes at least two courts in which the defendant can be sued, and the defendant who invokes it carries the burden. First, there must be an adequate alternative forum: ordinarily one where the defendant is amenable to process and that offers some real remedy, even a less generous one. Then the court weighs private and public interests. The private-interest factors, set out in Gulf Oil Corp. v. Gilbert (1947), include ease of access to sources of proof, the availability of compulsory process for unwilling witnesses and the cost of bringing willing ones, the chance to view the premises if that matters, the enforceability of a judgment, and every other practical problem that makes trial easy, quick and inexpensive. The public-interest factors include court congestion, the burden of jury duty on a community with no connection to the dispute, the local interest in deciding local controversies at home, and the advantage of trying a case where the court knows the law that governs it.
The plaintiff’s choice of forum counts for a great deal: unless the balance strongly favors the defendant, it should rarely be disturbed. That deference shrinks when the plaintiff is foreign, because the assumption that a plaintiff chose a convenient forum is much less reasonable. In Piper Aircraft Co. v. Reyno (1981), which arose from a plane crash in Scotland, the Supreme Court also held that the chance of less favorable law in the other forum ordinarily should not carry substantial weight, unless the remedy there is so inadequate that it is no remedy at all.
Inside the federal system, the doctrine now does less than it once did. Congress has provided for transfer between federal districts, under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a), for the convenience of parties and witnesses and in the interest of justice. So a federal court today dismisses for forum non conveniens mainly when the better forum is in another country, or occasionally a state court. Dismissals are often conditional, for example on the defendant’s agreement to submit to the foreign court and not to raise a time bar there.
States apply their own versions, by common law, statute or rule, and some have narrowed or reshaped the doctrine. Because it is a procedural rule about where cases are heard, the Supreme Court held in American Dredging Co. v. Miller (1994) that federal maritime law does not require state courts to apply the federal version.
A forum non conveniens dismissal is not a ruling on the merits. It sends the plaintiff to another court; it does not decide who should win.
Etymology
Forum in Lewis & Short begins with “what is out of doors . . .”, an open space outside the house, and its central sense is “The market-place, forum, in each city, as the principal place of meeting, where public affairs were discussed, courts of justice held, money transactions carried on”. From the place where courts sat, the word came to mean the court itself; that step is ours to note, not the dictionary’s.
Nōn is the ordinary Latin word for not, which the dictionary traces to an older form meaning nec unum, not one. Convĕnĭens is the participle of convĕnĭō, whose first sense is “To come together, meet together, assemble” and which also means “To fit with, in, or to something, to suit, be adapted to”. As an adjective the participle means “Fitting to something, appropriate to, meet, fit, suitable”. A forum non conveniens is, word for word, a court that does not fit the case.
Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries fŏrum, nōn, con-vĕnĭo, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.
In the opinions
Four passages from the Supreme Court, newest first, that explain what the doctrine is and how courts apply it. Each is quoted from the official United States Reports.
At bottom, the doctrine of forum non conveniens is nothing more or less than a supervening venue provision, permitting displacement of the ordinary rules of venue when, in light of certain conditions, the trial court thinks that jurisdiction ought to be declined. But venue is a matter that goes to process rather than substantive rights—determining which among various competent courts will decide the case.
A seaman sued in Louisiana, whose courts refuse to apply the doctrine in such cases; the Court held that federal maritime law did not force them to, because the doctrine is procedural.
The possibility of a change in substantive law should ordinarily not be given conclusive or even substantial weight in the forum non conveniens inquiry.
Survivors of passengers killed in a plane crash in Scotland sued the American manufacturers in the United States, where the law was more favorable to them; the Court upheld dismissal in favor of the Scottish courts.
These statutes are drawn with a necessary generality and usually give a plaintiff a choice of courts, so that he may be quite sure of some place in which to pursue his remedy. But the open door may admit those who seek not simply justice but perhaps justice blended with some harassment.
A Virginia warehouse owner sued over a fire in Virginia in a federal court in New York. Justice Jackson had just defined the doctrine as a court’s power to resist an imposition on its jurisdiction even when a venue statute allows the suit; here he explained why.
But unless the balance is strongly in favor of the defendant, the plaintiff’s choice of forum should rarely be disturbed.
After listing the private-interest factors, the Court stated the balance that the defendant must overcome.
Where it appears in the rules
The rule pages below use the phrase in their official text. Most are statutes or rules on when a court must or may decline a case, the deadline for moving to dismiss or transfer on this ground, appeals from such orders, and the effect of a dismissal. Each link opens the rule with its full verbatim text.
18 rule pages in 8 jurisdictions use “forum non conveniens” in their official text.
Illinois 4
- 735 ILCS 5/2-101.5 — Venue in actions asserting constitutional claims against the State.
- Ill. S. Ct. R. 187 — Motions on Grounds of Forum Non Conveniens (Illinois Supreme Court Rules)
- Ill. S. Ct. R. 306 — Interlocutory Appeals by Permission (Illinois Supreme Court Rules)
- Ill. S. Ct. R. 384 — Proceedings for the Transfer and Consolidation of Multicircuit Actions. (Illinois Supreme Court Rules)
Kentucky 3
Louisiana 5
- La. C.C.P. art. 74.2 — Custody Proceedings; Support; Forum Non Conveniens in the rule’s title
- La. C.C.P. art. 123 — Forum Non Conveniens in the rule’s title
- La. C.C.P. art. 124 — Forum Non Conveniens; Transfer to City Court in the rule’s title
- La. C.C.P. art. 593.2 — Class Actions; Forum Non Conveniens in the rule’s title
- La. C.C.P. art. 4852 — Change of Venue; City Court; Forum Non Conveniens in the rule’s title
Minnesota 1
Oklahoma 2
Several rulesets use English instead, so they are not counted above. New York’s CPLR 327(a) lets a court stay or dismiss when “in the interest of substantial justice the action should be heard in another forum”, and California’s Code of Civil Procedure § 418.10(a) lets a defendant move “To stay or dismiss the action on the ground of inconvenient forum”. Many states’ versions of the uniform child-custody and foreign-judgment acts speak of an inconvenient forum too.
Notable remarks
A footnote in which the Supreme Court traces where the doctrine came from. A spaced ellipsis marks where a citation has been left out.
The doctrine of forum non conveniens has a long history. It originated in Scotland, . . . and became part of the common law of many States, . . . . The doctrine was also frequently applied in federal admiralty actions. . . . In Williams v. Green Bay & Western R. Co., . . . the Court first indicated that motions to dismiss on grounds of forum non conveniens could be made in federal diversity actions. The doctrine became firmly established when Gilbert and Koster were decided one year later.
Noting that the doctrine did not fully take shape in American law until its 1947 decision in Gulf Oil Corp. v. Gilbert, the Court set out the earlier history in a footnote. Koster is Koster v. (American) Lumbermens Mutual Casualty Co., decided the same day as Gilbert.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between forum non conveniens and a transfer of venue?
A transfer moves a case to another court in the same system: under 28 U.S.C. § 1404(a), one federal district can send a case to another for convenience. Forum non conveniens ends the case in the first court so that the plaintiff can bring it in a different system, usually a foreign country’s courts, which a federal court cannot transfer a case to. In state courts, some states use the doctrine to move a case between their own counties, and many have statutes on transfer as well.
Who has the burden of proof?
The defendant who asks for dismissal. It must show that an adequate alternative forum is available and that the private and public interests weigh strongly in favor of trial there. Courts give the plaintiff’s choice of a home forum substantial deference, and somewhat less to a foreign plaintiff’s choice.
Can the plaintiff refile the case somewhere else?
Yes; that is the point. A forum non conveniens dismissal is not a judgment on the merits, and it assumes the plaintiff will sue in the alternative forum. Courts often attach conditions to protect the plaintiff, such as requiring the defendant to accept service there and to waive any statute-of-limitations defense that ripened while the case sat in the original court. Minnesota’s rule on dismissals, Rule 41.02(c), says so expressly: a dismissal “other than a dismissal for lack of jurisdiction, for forum non conveniens, or for failure to join a party indispensable pursuant to Rule 19, operates as an adjudication upon the merits”, so a forum non conveniens dismissal does not.
Does it matter that the law of the other country is less favorable to me?
Usually not much. The Supreme Court held in Piper Aircraft Co. v. Reyno (1981) that the possibility of less favorable law abroad ordinarily should not get conclusive or even substantial weight. The exception is when the other forum’s remedy is so clearly inadequate that it is no remedy at all.
Is forum non conveniens the same as lack of personal jurisdiction?
No. A court that lacks personal jurisdiction has no power to bind the defendant at all. Forum non conveniens is not a finding that the court lacks power. It asks only whether the court should decline to hear the case because another court is far better suited.