RulesofCivilProcedure.com Civil Procedure · Every State

Ex Abundanti Cautela

ex ăbundanti cautēlā

Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 16, 2026

Quick answerEx abundanti cautela is Latin for “out of abundant caution.” Courts use it to describe words a drafter put into a statute or other legal text that are not strictly needed, added only to remove any doubt about its meaning.

Pronunciation

There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.

  • Common US legal pronunciation: eks ab-un-DAN-tee kaw-TEE-luh, IPA /ɛks ˌæbənˈdænti kɔːˈtiːlə/. Some say eks ah-boon-DAHN-tee kow-TAY-lah, /ˌɑːbʊnˈdɑːnti kaʊˈteɪlə/.
  • Classical Latin (restored): eks ah-buun-DAHN-tee kow-TAY-lah, IPA [ɛks abʊnˈdantiː kau̯ˈteːlaː]. The u of abundanti was short, as in put, the au of cautēlā rhymed with how, and its ē was long.

Literal translation

  • ex — out of, from
  • abundanti — abundant, plentiful; a form of abundans, the present participle of the verb abundo, to overflow
  • cautela — caution, precaution

Put together: “out of abundant caution,” or in the English that courts often use instead, “out of an abundance of caution.”

What it means in law

Drafters sometimes say more than they need to. A statute may name a particular case that its general words already cover, or add an exception for something the main clause would never have reached. Words like these are said to be put in ex abundanti cautela: not to change the meaning, but to make sure no one misreads it.

The phrase matters because courts usually try to give every word of a statute some work to do. When one reading of a law would leave a clause with nothing to do, that is a reason to prefer another reading. The answer on the other side is that the clause may have been added only out of caution, and that redundant words are no proof of a different meaning. Neither argument wins automatically; a court weighs them with everything else in the text.

The Supreme Court described the habit in Fort Stewart Schools v. FLRA (1990). A federal statute required agencies to bargain with their employees’ unions over conditions of employment, which it defined as matters affecting working conditions, with exceptions that included matters relating to prohibited political activities and to the classification of positions. Schools run by the Army on a military base argued that working conditions most naturally meant the physical conditions of a job. Justice Scalia, for a unanimous Court, answered that the two exceptions would be needless on that reading, which supported the broader one. He granted that the exceptions might have been inserted out of caution, a drafting flaw, he added, so old that legal Latin has a name for it: ex abundanti cautela. But he noted that the schools did not make that argument. The Court upheld the ruling that the schools had to bargain over the union’s proposals on pay and fringe benefits.

The phrase often sits on one side of a contest between canons of construction. In Circuit City Stores, Inc. v. Adams (2001) the Federal Arbitration Act excluded the employment contracts of seamen, railroad employees and any other class of workers engaged in foreign or interstate commerce. The majority applied ejusdem generis and read the general words as covering only transportation workers, so the Act reached a retail employee’s arbitration agreement. Justice Souter, dissenting for four Justices, argued that Congress had named seamen and railroad workers out of special care not to disturb laws already written for them, so their mention said nothing to narrow the general words. In his view the specific terms were there ex abundanti cautela.

Courts also use the English form for other kinds of care: a judge may decide a point, or give a warning, out of an abundance of caution. In that looser use the words simply mean that the step was taken to be safe, not because it was required.

Etymology

Ex is the preposition Lewis & Short gloss “out of, from”. The dictionary divides abundo as ăb-undo and gives its literal sense, of a wave, as “to flow over and down, to overflow”; that the second part of the word is unda, a wave, is our reading of that division. Its present participle abundans is glossed “overflowing” and, in a transferred sense, “Existing in abundance, copious, abundant”, with an example in the same ablative form as the phrase: abundanti etiam pecuniā (Cic. Quint. 12, 40). The dictionary’s own entry for abundans only sends the reader back to abundo.

The first two words were already a Latin idiom. Lewis & Short record ex abundanti as an adverbial phrase meaning “superabundantly”, citing Quintilian and the Digest (Quint. 4, 5, 15; 5, 6, 2; Dig. 33, 7, 12, § 46). The dictionary does not record the longer phrase with cautela.

Cautēla is glossed “caution, precaution”. Lewis & Short derive it from cautus and the verb caveo, and mark it as mostly later than the classical period. In the Roman legal writers it could also mean “a surety, security”. Put together, ex abundanti cautela is “out of overflowing caution”; that rendering is ours.

Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries ex, ăb-undo, cautēla, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.

In the opinions

Two passages from the official United States Reports: one from the Court and one from a dissent. A spaced ellipsis marks where a footnote number has been left out.

It might reasonably be argued, of course, that these two exceptions are indeed technically unnecessary, and were inserted out of an abundance of caution

Fort Stewart Schools v. Federal Labor Relations Authority, 495 U.S. 641, 646 (1990) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice Scalia

Having said that two of the statute’s exceptions would be needless on the schools’ reading, the unanimous Court considered the obvious reply. The sentence goes on, after a dash, to call such caution an old drafting flaw that gave legal Latin the phrase ex abundanti cautela.

The Court has understood this point before, holding that the existence of a special reason for emphasizing specific examples of a statutory class can negate any inference that an otherwise unqualified general phrase was meant to apply only to matters ejusdem generis. . . . On the Court’s own reading of the history, then, the explanation for the catchall is not ejusdem generis; instead, the explanation for the specifics is ex abundanti cautela, abundance of caution, see Fort Stewart Schools v. FLRA, 495 U. S. 641, 646 (1990).

Circuit City Stores, Inc. v. Adams, 532 U.S. 105, 140 (2001) · Supreme Court of the United States · Justice Souter, dissenting opinion

Writing for four dissenting Justices, Justice Souter argued that Congress had a special reason to name seamen and railroad employees, so their mention did not narrow the general words that followed. The majority read the exclusion more narrowly.

Where it appears in the rules

No rule on this site uses “ex abundanti cautela” in its official text.

No rule on this site uses the English form, out of abundant caution or an abundance of caution, in its official text either. The phrase is a tool for reading texts, not a term the rules themselves use.

Frequently asked questions

What does ex abundanti cautela mean?

It is Latin for “out of abundant caution.” In law it describes words that a drafter included even though they were not strictly needed, to rule out a reading the drafter feared.

Do words added out of caution have any legal effect?

The argument that words were added out of caution is an argument that they do not change the meaning of the text. Courts weigh it against the opposite presumption, that every word of a statute should be given some effect. Which argument prevails depends on the text and its context; in Fort Stewart Schools v. FLRA (1990) the Supreme Court noted the possibility but did not rest on it, because the party that stood to gain from it had not made the argument.

How does ex abundanti cautela relate to ejusdem generis?

They often point in opposite directions. Ejusdem generis reads general words in light of the specific items listed before them, which can narrow the general words. Saying that the specific items were listed out of caution is a way of arguing that they narrow nothing. In Circuit City Stores, Inc. v. Adams (2001) the majority applied ejusdem generis, and the dissent answered with ex abundanti cautela.

Is “out of an abundance of caution” the same thing?

Yes, it is the English version, and many opinions use the English instead of the Latin. Besides describing redundant drafting, the English form is used for any step taken to be safe rather than because it was required.

Is ex abundanti cautela a rule courts must follow?

No. It is a description and an argument, not a binding rule. Calling a provision cautionary is one way to explain why a text says something twice, and a court may accept or reject that explanation in a given case.

This page explains a legal term. It is legal information, not legal advice, and it cannot tell you how the law applies to your situation. Whether a court treats particular words as mere caution or gives them independent effect depends on the text, its context and the interpretive rules of the court deciding. If the outcome matters, talk to a lawyer or your court’s self-help center.