Scienter
scĭenter
Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 13, 2026
Pronunciation
There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers say the word, and how a Roman would have said it.
- Common US legal pronunciation: sy-EN-ter, IPA /saɪˈɛntər/. Some say see-EN-ter, /siˈɛntər/.
- Classical Latin (restored): skih-EN-tehr, IPA [skɪˈɛntɛr]. Latin sc before i was a plain sk, and the stress falls on -en-, a syllable closed by the n.
Literal translation
- scienter — knowingly; an adverb formed from sciens, “knowing,” the present participle of scio, “to know”
Taken alone, the word means “knowingly.” In law it has become a noun naming the knowing state of mind itself.
What it means in law
Scienter is the law’s word for a guilty mind of a particular kind: knowing what one is doing, and usually intending to deceive or to do wrong. It matters most in fraud. A false statement made innocently, or carelessly, is not fraud in the full sense; the speaker has to have known the statement was false, or at least not cared whether it was true, and meant others to rely on it.
The word’s leading modern home is federal securities law. Section 10(b) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and the Securities and Exchange Commission’s Rule 10b-5 forbid manipulative and deceptive practices in buying and selling securities. In Ernst & Ernst v. Hochfelder (1976), investors sued an accounting firm that had audited a brokerage whose president defrauded them, claiming only that the firm had been careless in its audits. The Supreme Court held that a private suit for damages under the rule requires scienter, which it defined as a mental state embracing intent to deceive, manipulate or defraud. Negligence alone is not enough. The Court left open whether recklessness can satisfy the requirement. Every federal court of appeals to decide the question has held that it can, though they differ on how reckless the conduct must be; the Supreme Court has noted that consensus without deciding the question itself.
Scienter must also be pleaded, and here the general rule and securities law part ways. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 9(b) requires fraud itself to be pleaded with particularity but lets a party allege a state of mind generally. That does not license a bare conclusion. In Ashcroft v. Iqbal (2009) the Court said the rule only spares a party the heightened standard for fraud; the allegation must still be plausible under the ordinary pleading rule. For private securities-fraud suits, Congress demanded more in the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995: the complaint must state with particularity facts giving rise to a strong inference that the defendant acted with the required state of mind. In Tellabs, Inc. v. Makor Issues & Rights, Ltd. (2007) the Court explained that a court must weigh the allegations as a whole, consider innocent explanations as well, and let the complaint go forward only if a reasonable person would find the inference of scienter cogent and at least as compelling as any opposing inference. A motive, such as selling shares before bad news, can help, but its absence is not fatal.
In criminal law the word survives as one of many older names for the mental element of a crime. The Supreme Court has listed it alongside mens rea, malice aforethought, guilty knowledge and similar terms, as in Morissette v. United States (1952). Modern criminal statutes and codes more often speak of acting purposely, knowingly, recklessly or negligently, and courts speak of a presumption in favor of a scienter requirement when a criminal statute is silent about the mental state.
Scienter is usually narrower than mens rea, the general term for any mental element of a crime, which can include recklessness or negligence. It means knowledge or intent to deceive and, in the federal courts of appeals’ securities cases, recklessness as well, but not negligence. It is the opposite of good faith: a person who acted bona fide, honestly believing in what he said or did, generally lacks scienter.
Etymology
Lewis & Short’s own entry for scĭenter is only a cross-reference to the verb scĭo. Under scĭo the dictionary gives the general sense “to know, in the widest signif. of the word; to understand; perceive; to have knowledge of or skill in any thing”, and for the adverb scĭenter the glosses “knowingly, understandingly, wisely, skilfully, expertly, etc.” The participle sciens, used of a person acting with full awareness, it renders “knowingly, wittingly, purposely, intentionally”.
In classical Latin the adverb was often praise: to speak scienter was to speak with skill. The law kept only the sense of acting with knowledge, and then turned the adverb into a noun for that state of mind; that account of the shift is ours, not the dictionary’s.
Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entry scĭo, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.
In the opinions
Four passages from Supreme Court opinions on scienter in securities fraud, which define the term, draw its line against negligence, and set the standard for pleading it. Each is quoted from the official United States Reports.
To establish liability under § 10(b) and Rule 10b–5, a private plaintiff must prove that the defendant acted with scienter, “a mental state embracing intent to deceive, manipulate, or defraud.”
Setting out what a private securities-fraud plaintiff must prove, the Court gave the definition of scienter it had first stated in a footnote to Ernst & Ernst v. Hochfelder (1976); the inner quotation is from that case.
Although the extensive legislative history of the 1934 Act is bereft of any explicit explanation of Congress’ intent, we think the relevant portions of that history support our conclusion that § 10 (b) was addressed to practices that involve some element of scienter and cannot be read to impose liability for negligent conduct alone.
Investors had sued an accounting firm only for negligence in auditing a brokerage whose president defrauded them. Turning from the statute’s words to its history, the Court found the same answer.
Yet the inference of scienter must be more than merely “reasonable” or “permissible”—it must be cogent and compelling, thus strong in light of other explanations. A complaint will survive, we hold, only if a reasonable person would deem the inference of scienter cogent and at least as compelling as any opposing inference one could draw from the facts alleged.
Shareholders accused a company’s chief executive of misleading them about demand for its products. Interpreting the 1995 statute’s demand for a strong inference of scienter, the Court stated its holding.
Every Court of Appeals that has considered the issue has held that a plaintiff may meet the scienter requirement by showing that the defendant acted intentionally or recklessly, though the Circuits differ on the degree of recklessness required.
In a footnote, the Court noted that it had reserved the recklessness question in Ernst & Ernst and described how the courts of appeals had answered it since.
Where it appears in the rules
No rule on this site uses “scienter” in its official text.
The idea is there in English. Federal Rule 9(b) provides that “Malice, intent, knowledge, and other conditions of a person's mind may be alleged generally”, while fraud itself must be pleaded with particularity. For private securities-fraud claims, a federal statute that is not on this site sets the stricter strong-inference standard described above.
Frequently asked questions
What does scienter mean?
Knowledge of wrongdoing, or intent to deceive. It is the mental state that turns a false statement into fraud. In federal securities law the Supreme Court has defined it as a mental state embracing intent to deceive, manipulate or defraud.
Is negligence enough to prove scienter?
No. In Ernst & Ernst v. Hochfelder (1976) the Supreme Court held that a private damages suit under Rule 10b-5 cannot rest on negligence alone. Recklessness is a different question: the Court has left it open, and the federal courts of appeals that have decided it accept recklessness, in varying degrees.
How do you plead scienter in a securities case?
Under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act, a private plaintiff must state with particularity facts giving rise to a strong inference that the defendant acted with the required state of mind. Under Tellabs (2007), the inference must be at least as compelling as any innocent explanation, judged on all the allegations together. Outside that statute, Federal Rule 9(b) lets knowledge and intent be alleged generally, though under Ashcroft v. Iqbal (2009) the allegation must still be plausible, not a bare conclusion.
What is the difference between scienter and mens rea?
Mens rea is the general name for the mental element of a crime, which can range from purpose down to negligence. Scienter usually means something more specific: knowledge, or intent to deceive, and in the federal courts of appeals’ securities cases recklessness as well, but not negligence. In criminal law the two words are sometimes used loosely for the same idea, and courts speak of a presumption in favor of a scienter requirement when a criminal statute says nothing about the defendant’s state of mind.
Does motive prove scienter?
It can help but is not required. In Tellabs the Supreme Court said that motive, such as a personal financial gain, can weigh heavily toward an inference of scienter, but that the absence of a motive allegation is not fatal. The allegations are weighed as a whole.