Nemo Judex in Causa Sua
nēmō jūdex in causā suā · also written nemo iudex in causa sua; no man can be a judge in his own case
Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 13, 2026
Pronunciation
There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers and judges say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.
- Common US legal pronunciation: NEE-moh JOO-deks in KAW-zuh SOO-uh, IPA /ˈniːmoʊ ˈdʒuːdɛks ɪn ˈkɔːzə ˈsuːə/. Some lawyers say NAY-moh, /ˈneɪmoʊ/, for the first word.
- Classical Latin (restored): NAY-moh YOO-deks in KOW-sah SU-ah, IPA [ˈneːmoː ˈjuːdɛks ɪn ˈkau̯saː ˈsʊaː]. Latin had no English J sound, au rhymed with “cow,” the u of sŭa was short, as in put, and the final *ā*s of the ablative were long.
Literal translation
- nemo — no one
- judex — a judge
- in — in
- causa — a case, a lawsuit (here in the ablative, causā)
- sua — his own, one’s own
Put together: “no one [should be] a judge in his own case.” The Latin has no verb; the “should be” is understood.
What it means in law
The maxim states one of the oldest ideas about fair judging: a person with a stake in a dispute may not decide it. The Supreme Court states it in English. None of the Court’s opinions saved for this dictionary uses the Latin words; they say, as In re Murchison (1955) put it, that no man can be a judge in his own case.
A rule of due process. In American law the principle lives in the Due Process Clauses. Murchison called a fair trial in a fair tribunal a basic requirement of due process. Fairness requires that the judge have no actual bias, but the law also tries to prevent even the probability of unfairness, so a judge may be disqualified without any proof that he was in fact biased. The Court asks an objective question: whether the average judge in that position is likely to be neutral, or whether the risk of bias is too high to be constitutionally tolerable.
A stake in the outcome. The plainest case is money. In Tumey v. Ohio (1927) a village mayor tried liquor-law cases and was paid his fees out of the costs only when he convicted. The Court held that trying a defendant before a judge with a direct, personal, substantial, pecuniary interest in convicting him denies due process.
Accuser and judge. The principle also bars a judge from deciding a charge he helped bring. In Murchison a Michigan judge had acted as a one-man grand jury, questioned witnesses in secret, charged two of them with contempt, and then tried and convicted them himself. The Court reversed. In Williams v. Pennsylvania (2016) the chief justice of Pennsylvania had, years earlier as district attorney, decided to seek the death penalty against the defendant, and later took part in deciding the defendant’s challenge to that sentence. The Court held that a judge who had significant, personal involvement as a prosecutor in a critical decision in the defendant’s case may not sit on it.
Limits. The Constitution sets a floor, not a full code. In 1927 Tumey said that many questions of judicial qualification, such as kinship, personal bias, state policy and remoteness of interest, would seem generally to be matters for the legislature. Later cases have not left every question of bias to legislatures: Williams, a case with no money at stake, applied an objective test that requires recusal when the likelihood of bias is too high to be constitutionally tolerable. Still, most disqualification therefore turns on statutes and court rules, which commonly reach further than due process requires.
An older form. The idea is older than the Fourteenth Amendment. In Calder v. Bull (1798) Justice Chase, writing one of the Justices’ separate seriatim opinions, listed a law that makes a man a judge in his own cause among the acts a legislature cannot rightly pass.
Lawyers raise the principle by moving for recusal or disqualification of the judge. Recusal is the procedure; nemo judex is the principle behind it.
Etymology
Nemo is “no man, no one, nobody”. Judex is “a judge”, a word Lewis & Short derive from jūs and dīco ([jus-, 2. dico]), so that a judge is, on our reading, one who declares the law. Causa had many senses; in the language of the courts it meant “a cause, judicial process, lawsuit”. Sua is a form of suus, “of or belonging to himself, herself, etc.; his own, her own, etc. . . .”
The saved entries do not record the maxim itself, and no saved opinion uses the Latin, so we do not suggest who first framed it in these words.
Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries nēmō^, jūdex, causa, sŭus, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.
In the opinions
The Supreme Court states this principle in English. The three passages below are quoted from the official United States Reports; a spaced ellipsis marks where a citation has been left out.
A fair trial in a fair tribunal is a basic requirement of due process. Fairness of course requires an absence of actual bias in the trial of cases. But our system of law has always endeavored to prevent even the probability of unfairness. To this end no man can be a judge in his own case and no man is permitted to try cases where he has an interest in the outcome. That interest cannot be defined with precision. Circumstances and relationships must be considered.
A Michigan judge had sat as a one-man grand jury and then tried the witnesses he charged with contempt. The Court explained why that violated due process.
The due process guarantee that “no man can be a judge in his own case” would have little substance if it did not disqualify a former prosecutor from sitting in judgment of a prosecution in which he or she had made a critical decision.
The words in quotation marks are the Court quoting In re Murchison (1955). Pennsylvania’s chief justice had decided, as district attorney, to seek the death penalty against the defendant.
All questions of judicial qualification may not involve constitutional validity. Thus matters of kinship, personal bias, state policy, remoteness of interest, would seem generally to be matters merely of legislative discretion. . . . But it certainly violates the Fourteenth Amendment, and deprives a defendant in a criminal case of due process of law, to subject his liberty or property to the judgment of a court the judge of which has a direct, personal, substantial, pecuniary interest in reaching a conclusion against him in his case.
An Ohio village mayor tried liquor-law cases and collected his fees only when he convicted. The passage does not use the maxim’s words but states the financial side of it.
Where it appears in the rules
No rule on this site uses “nemo judex in causa sua” in its official text.
The rulesets carry the principle in their disqualification rules, in English. Texas Rule 18b(a) requires a judge to step aside when “the judge has served as a lawyer in the matter in controversy”, and also when the judge knows that he or she has an interest in the subject matter. California’s Code of Civil Procedure § 170.1(a) disqualifies a judge who “has a financial interest in the subject matter in a proceeding or in a party to the proceeding”. Louisiana’s Code of Civil Procedure article 151 provides for recusal of a judge who is “interested in the cause or its outcome”.
Frequently asked questions
What does nemo judex in causa sua mean?
“No one should be a judge in his own case.” A person who has a stake in a dispute, or who acted as the accuser in it, should not be the one to decide it.
Is nemo judex part of American constitutional law?
The principle is. The Supreme Court treats it as part of the due process the Fourteenth Amendment guarantees, though it states it in English. In In re Murchison (1955) the Court said that a fair trial in a fair tribunal is a basic requirement of due process and that no man can be a judge in his own case.
Does a judge have to be actually biased to be disqualified?
No. The Supreme Court asks an objective question: whether the average judge in that position is likely to be neutral, or whether the risk of bias is too high to be constitutionally tolerable. A judge with a direct financial stake in the result, or one who earlier made a critical decision in the case as a prosecutor, may be disqualified without proof that he was in fact unfair.
Does every conflict of interest violate the Constitution?
No. In Tumey v. Ohio (1927) the Court said that many questions about a judge’s qualification, such as kinship, personal bias and remote interests, would seem generally to be for the legislature. Later cases such as Williams v. Pennsylvania (2016) also reach interests other than money, requiring recusal when the likelihood of bias is too high to be constitutionally tolerable, but that is a high bar. Statutes and court rules on disqualification often go further than the Constitution, so a judge may have to step aside under a rule even when due process would not require it.
How do I ask a judge to step aside?
By a motion to recuse or disqualify the judge, made under the court’s own rules, which set the grounds, the timing and who decides the motion. The rules differ from court to court, and a lawyer can explain them.