RulesofCivilProcedure.com Civil Procedure · Every State

Ex Gratia

ex grātĭā

Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 16, 2026

Quick answerEx gratia means “as a matter of grace”: a payment or other relief given voluntarily or at a court’s discretion, not because anyone has a legal right to it.

Pronunciation

There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how American lawyers usually say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.

  • Common US legal pronunciation: eks GRAY-shee-uh, IPA /ɛks ˈɡreɪʃiə/. Many say eks GRAH-shee-uh, /ˈɡrɑːʃiə/, or GRAH-tee-uh, /ˈɡrɑːtiə/; all are heard.
  • Classical Latin (restored): eks GRAH-tih-ah, IPA [ɛks ˈɡraːtɪaː]. The first ā of grātĭā is long and carries the stress, the i is short and said like the i in pit, and the final ā of this form is long.

Literal translation

  • ex — out of, from; by reason of
  • gratia — favor, kindness, goodwill (here in the form that follows ex)

Put together: “out of favor,” or more naturally, “as a matter of grace.”

What it means in law

Most of what courts and governments do is owed. A party who wins a judgment has a right to it; a taxpayer who overpays has a right to a refund the statute allows. Something given ex gratia is different. It comes as a favor, out of fairness or discretion, and the person who receives it could not have demanded it.

The phrase turns up in a few settings. The best known is the ex gratia payment: money paid voluntarily, usually by a business, an insurer or a government, without admitting that it owes anything. Such a payment may settle a grievance while leaving the question of legal liability open. Whether a particular payment really was voluntary, and what follows from it, depends on its terms and the law that governs it.

Courts also use the phrase for relief that rests in a judge’s discretion. In Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Florida (1935), a railroad had collected higher freight rates for two years under a federal order that the Supreme Court later struck down because the agency’s findings were incomplete. The agency then made the same order again, with proper findings, and the Court upheld it. Shippers and the State of Florida asked for the extra charges back. The Court recognized the general rule that what a litigant loses under a judgment later reversed should be restored, but it held that restitution of that kind is equitable and discretionary. The claimant must show that the other side cannot in good conscience keep the money. Because the higher rates were the lawful ones in substance, and had failed only through a defect of procedure, the Court denied restitution altogether. Four Justices dissented, in an opinion by Justice Roberts.

The phrase can also describe a benefit a statute grants as a matter of legislative grace. In United States v. Koppers Co. (1955), two companies had won reductions of their wartime excess-profits taxes under a relief provision, § 722 of the tax code, after the taxes had come due. The Court held that the reductions were not retroactive, so the companies still owed interest on the amounts later taken off, from the dates the taxes were due until the reductions were granted, and in a footnote it quoted Judge Learned Hand’s description of that relief as a favor granted ex gratia. Two Justices dissented.

The opposite of ex gratia is a matter of right, something a person can insist on. The line matters because a favor can usually be refused, or granted on conditions, while a right must be honored.

Etymology

Ex is the preposition Lewis & Short gloss “out of, from”. One of its uses, which fits this phrase, is to give the cause or reason for something: “from, through, by, by reason of, on account of”.

Grātĭā is the form of grātĭa that follows ex. The dictionary divides the noun’s meaning into the favor one finds with others and the favor one shows to them. The second is the one at work here: “Favor which one shows to another, mark of favor, kindness, courtesy, service, obligation”. The same form, used on its own after a noun, came to mean “in favor of, on account of, for the sake of”, the sense English keeps in exempli gratia, “for the sake of example,” abbreviated e.g.

The dictionary entries cited here do not record ex gratia as a phrase. Reading it as “out of favor,” and so “as a matter of grace,” is ours, built from the two words.

Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries ex, grātĭa, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.

In the opinions

Three passages from two Supreme Court cases. Two are other judges’ words that the Court quoted and adopted, and their context lines name who wrote them. Each is quoted from the official United States Reports.

It is ex gratia, resting in the exercise of a sound discretion, and the court will not order it where the justice of the case does not call for it, nor where the process is set aside for a mere slip.

Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Florida, 295 U.S. 301, 310 (1935) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice Cardozo

These are not the Court’s own words: Justice Cardozo was quoting the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania in Gould v. McFall, which had just said that restitution is not a matter of mere right.

The claimant to prevail must show that the money was received in such circumstances that the possessor will give offense to equity and good conscience if permitted to retain it.

Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Florida, 295 U.S. 301, 309 (1935) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice Cardozo

A page earlier, in his own words, Justice Cardozo set out what a claimant for restitution has to show.

We do not so regard § 722; on the contrary it was a favor; it presupposed that, even after taking into account the ameliatory conditions of §721, the tax was due unless ex gratia the blow was softened; it was a tempering of the wind to the shorn lamb.

United States v. Koppers Co., 348 U.S. 254, 269, n. 18 (1955) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice Burton

In a footnote the Court quoted Judge Learned Hand, writing for the federal court of appeals in American Coast Line v. Commissioner, on the nature of excess-profits tax relief. The spelling ameliatory is the official report’s.

Where it appears in the rules

No rule on this site uses “ex gratia” in its official text.

Rules of procedure deal with what parties are entitled to, so the phrase has little place in them. They express the same contrast in English, by saying that a court may grant some kinds of relief rather than that it must.

Frequently asked questions

What is an ex gratia payment?

A payment made voluntarily, as a favor or out of fairness, rather than because the payer accepts that the law requires it. Businesses, insurers and governments sometimes make them to resolve a complaint without admitting liability. The terms of the payment, and the law that governs it, decide what effect it has, for example whether the person who accepts it gives up any claims.

Does an ex gratia payment admit fault?

It is usually offered on the footing that it does not. That is the point of calling it ex gratia. But labels do not always control, so anyone offered such a payment, especially one tied to a release of claims, should read its terms carefully.

What is the opposite of ex gratia?

Something owed as of right: a payment or remedy a person can demand and a court must give if the conditions are met. In Atlantic Coast Line R. Co. v. Florida (1935), the Supreme Court quoted a Pennsylvania court’s statement that restitution after a reversed judgment is not a matter of mere right but ex gratia, so a court may refuse it when justice does not call for it.

Can a court refuse relief that is ex gratia?

Yes. That is what makes it ex gratia. In Atlantic Coast Line, the Court denied restitution entirely, even though the general rule favors restoring what was lost under a reversed judgment, because the higher rates would have been lawful but for a defect in the agency’s findings, and the claimants had not shown that equity and good conscience required the railroad to give the money back.

This page explains a legal term. It is legal information, not legal advice, and it cannot tell you how the law applies to your situation. Whether a payment or form of relief is a matter of right or of grace depends on the statute, contract or doctrine that governs it. If the outcome matters, talk to a lawyer or your court’s self-help center.