RulesofCivilProcedure.com Civil Procedure · Every State

Alter Ego

alter ĕgō

Legal Latin Dictionary · Last verified November 13, 2026

Quick answerIn law, an alter ego is a company or person so dominated by another that a court disregards their separate identities and holds one responsible for the other’s obligations.

Pronunciation

There is no single official pronunciation of legal Latin. What follows is how most American lawyers say the phrase, and how a Roman would have said it.

  • Common US legal pronunciation: AWL-ter EE-goh, IPA /ˌɔːltər ˈiːɡoʊ/. Many people say AL-ter, /ˈæltər/, and some say EG-oh, /ˈɛɡoʊ/; all are heard.
  • Classical Latin (restored): AHL-ter EH-go, IPA [ˈaltɛr ˈɛɡɔ]. Both words stress the first syllable. The final o of ego was long before the classical period and again after Augustus, but Lewis & Short note that it is always short in the great poets of the classical age, such as Catullus, Virgil and Horace, so the classical form given here has the short vowel.

Literal translation

  • alter — the other of two; a second
  • ego — I

Put together: “another I,” or “a second self.”

What it means in law

The law usually respects a corporation or limited liability company as a person of its own. That separateness is the point of forming one: the owners can invest without risking everything else they have, and the company’s debts are its own. Alter ego is the name for the exception. When an owner so dominates a company that the company has no real existence apart from the owner, a court may treat the two as one and hold the owner liable for the company’s debts. Lawyers call this piercing the corporate veil.

Courts do not pierce lightly, and the test varies from state to state. Most ask, in one form or another, two questions. Was there such unity of ownership and control that the company’s separate personality did not really exist? And would respecting the separation produce fraud or an unjust result? Factors courts weigh include mixing personal and company money, starting the business with far too little capital for its risks, ignoring corporate formalities, and using the company to dodge existing obligations. No single factor decides the case, and owning all the stock is not enough by itself.

The Supreme Court described the two traditional grounds in First National City Bank v. Banco Para el Comercio Exterior de Cuba (1983), known as Bancec. A company may be held liable for its owner, or the owner for the company, where control is so extensive that it creates a relationship of principal and agent, or where honoring the separate entity would work fraud or injustice. The Court applied those principles to a Cuban state bank. It held that government instrumentalities start with a presumption that they are separate from their government, but that the presumption gave way there, because Cuba would otherwise have collected on the bank’s claim in an American court while avoiding liability for seizing the other side’s property.

The phrase has a second, narrower use in agency law. An officer high enough in a company may be treated as its alter ego, so that the officer’s acts count as the company’s own. The Supreme Court noted that ground in Burlington Industries, Inc. v. Ellerth (1998), a sexual-harassment case, though no party relied on it there.

The label invites shortcuts, and the Court has warned against them. In Bancec it said that phrases such as alter ego and mere instrumentality must not take the place of careful analysis. Calling a company an alter ego states a conclusion; the facts have to support it.

Some legislatures have regulated how such claims are brought. Oklahoma’s 12 O.S. § 682(B), for example, bars suit against an officer, director or shareholder for a corporation’s debt until a judgment against the corporation has gone unsatisfied, and says the bar covers “claims based on vicarious liability and alter ego”.

Etymology

Alter is the Latin word for one of a pair. Lewis & Short gloss it “the other of two, one of two, the other”, and they record the phrase itself: “Alter ego, a second self, of very intimate friends”, noting that in the classical period it is found perhaps only in Cicero’s letters. One of the examples they give is te me esse alterum (Cic. Fam. 7, 5), which we translate as “that you are my second self.” Ego is the pronoun “I”; its entry sends the reader to the same place, with the note the combination alter ego v. under alter.

So the Romans used the phrase for a close friend, someone as near to you as yourself. The legal use keeps the idea of two persons who are really one but turns it to a harder purpose: a company that is nothing but its owner’s second self. That connection is ours, not the dictionary’s.

Source: Charlton T. Lewis and Charles Short, A Latin Dictionary (1879), entries alter, ĕgō^, via the Perseus Digital Library (Tufts University). Glosses in quotation marks are quoted from it.

In the opinions

Two Supreme Court passages that state the doctrine in its two senses. The first does not use the Latin words; it states the grounds on which the label rests. Each is quoted from the official United States Reports; a spaced ellipsis marks where a citation has been left out.

Thus, where a corporate entity is so extensively controlled by its owner that a relationship of principal and agent is created, we have held that one may be held liable for the actions of the other. . . . In addition, our cases have long recognized “the broader equitable principle that the doctrine of corporate entity, recognized generally and for most purposes, will not be regarded when to do so would work fraud or injustice.”

First Nat. City Bank v. Banco Para El Comercio, 462 U.S. 611, 629 (1983) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice O’Connor

Having said that a corporation is not to be treated as separate from its owners in all circumstances, the Court named the two grounds its cases had recognized. The inner quotation is from Taylor v. Standard Gas Co. (1939), as the Court cites it.

Subsection (a) addresses direct liability, where the employer acts with tortious intent, and indirect liability, where the agent’s high rank in the company makes him or her the employer’s alter ego. None of the parties contend Slowik’s rank imputes liability under this principle.

Burlington Industries, Inc. v. Ellerth, 524 U.S. 742, 758 (1998) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice Kennedy

Deciding when an employer is liable for a supervisor’s harassment, the Court worked through a list of grounds on which an employer answers for an employee’s wrongs outside the scope of the job. Subsection (a) of that list covers wrongs the employer itself intended.

Where it appears in the rules

1 rule page in 1 jurisdiction uses “alter ego” in its official text.

Notable remarks

The parties and amici have repeatedly referred to the phrases that have tended to dominate discussion about the independent status of separately constituted juridical entities, debating whether “to pierce the corporate veil,” and whether Bancec is an “alter ego” or a “mere instrumentality” of the Cuban Government. In Berkey v. Third Avenue R. Co., 244 N. Y. 84, 155 N. E. 58 (1926), Justice (then Judge) Cardozo warned in circumstances similar to those presented here against permitting worn epithets to substitute for rigorous analysis.

First Nat. City Bank v. Banco Para El Comercio, 462 U.S. 611, 623 (1983) · Supreme Court of the United States · opinion of Justice O’Connor

Before stating the governing principles, the Court commented on the labels the parties had been using, and invoked a warning by Benjamin Cardozo, then a judge of New York’s highest court.

Frequently asked questions

What does alter ego mean in law?

It describes a company, or sometimes a person, so completely controlled by another that the law treats the two as one. If a corporation is its owner’s alter ego, a court may hold the owner personally liable for the corporation’s debts, or the corporation liable for the owner’s.

What is piercing the corporate veil?

It is what a court does when it finds a company to be its owner’s alter ego: it looks past the company’s separate legal existence and reaches the owner. Courts generally require both domination by the owner and some unfairness, such as fraud or an unjust result, that would follow from respecting the separation.

Is owning all of a company’s stock enough to make it an alter ego?

No. A sole shareholder is still generally protected. Courts look for much more, such as treating company money as personal money, leaving the company without enough capital to meet its likely obligations, or using it to escape debts, and they also ask whether respecting the company’s separate existence would be unjust.

Can a subsidiary be treated as its parent company’s alter ego?

It can, but the same strict test applies. A parent that owns and oversees a subsidiary is not liable for its debts just because of that ownership. Courts usually require control so complete that the subsidiary has no real will of its own, together with an unfair result if the separation is respected.

Is alter ego a separate claim I can sue on?

Courts differ. In many places alter ego is treated as a way of holding someone liable on an underlying claim, such as a contract or a judgment, rather than as a claim of its own. Some statutes also set conditions; Oklahoma, for instance, requires an unsatisfied judgment against the corporation before such a claim can be brought against its officers, directors or shareholders.

This page explains a legal term. It is legal information, not legal advice, and it cannot tell you how the law applies to your situation. Whether a court will disregard a company’s separate existence depends on the facts and on the law of the state, or other jurisdiction, whose law governs the company. If the outcome matters, talk to a lawyer or your court’s self-help center.