Rule 1.1105.Discretionary
Division XI: Declaratory Judgments · Last amended February 15, 2002 · Last verified November 11, 2026
Full Text of Rule 1.1105
Amendment History
[Report 1943; November 9, 2001, effective February 15, 2002]
Plain-English Summary
The power to declare rights is broad, but Rule 1.1105 keeps it from being used to produce rulings that settle nothing. The court may refuse to render a declaratory judgment or decree where it would not, if rendered, terminate the uncertainty or controversy giving rise to the proceeding.
The test looks at what the declaration would accomplish. If answering the question would leave the parties as unsure of their position as before, because the dispute turns on facts or issues the declaration would not reach, the court may decline. The rule says "may": it gives the court discretion rather than requiring it to refuse.
Frequently Asked Questions
Must the court grant every request for a declaratory judgment?
No. Rule 1.1105 lets the court refuse a declaratory judgment or decree that would not terminate the uncertainty or controversy giving rise to the proceeding.
What is the court looking at when it decides whether to refuse?
Whether the declaration, if rendered, would end the uncertainty or controversy that led to the case.
Is refusal required when a declaration would not settle the dispute?
The rule says the court may refuse, so the decision is left to the court's discretion.
Does this limit the broad power in Rule 1.1101?
It tempers it. Rule 1.1101 grants the general power to declare rights, and Rule 1.1105 lets the court decline to use it where a declaration would not resolve the dispute.
Can a refusal be reviewed?
Rule 1.1107 provides that orders, judgments or decrees under rules 1.1101 through 1.1106 may be reviewed as other judgments, orders or decrees, and that includes this rule.