RulesofCivilProcedure.com Civil Procedure · Every State

10-128.Person discharged again imprisoned.

Article X. Habeas Corpus · Not amended since adoption on record · Last verified July 20, 2026

In one sentenceSection 10-128 protects someone discharged on habeas corpus from being reimprisoned for the same cause, except through a later indictment or a court's legal order, and it lists three situations -- a cured proof defect, a corrected civil judgment, or corrected legal formalities -- that don't count as the "same cause."

Full Text of 735 ILCS 5/10-128

Text size

No person who has been discharged by order of the court on a habeas corpus, shall be again imprisoned, restrained or kept in custody for the same cause, unless he or she is afterwards indicted for the same offense, nor unless by the legal order or process of the court wherein he or she is bound by recognizance to appear. The following shall not be deemed to be the same cause:
1. If, after a discharge for a defect of proof, or any material defect in the commitment, in a criminal case, the prisoner is again arrested on sufficient proof, and committed by legal process for the same offense.
2. If, in a civil action, the party has been discharged for any illegality in the judgment or process, and is afterwards imprisoned by legal process for the same cause of action.
3. Generally, whenever the discharge is ordered on account of the non-observance of any of the forms required by law, the party may be a second time imprisoned if the cause is legal and the forms required by law observed.

Plain-English Summary

Section 10-128 gives a discharged person a real, if bounded, protection. No person discharged by order of the court on habeas corpus shall again be imprisoned, restrained, or held in custody for the same cause, unless that person is afterward indicted for the same offense, or unless it's by the legal order or process of the court where that person is bound by recognizance to appear.

The section then narrows what counts as the "same cause" through three examples. If a person was discharged in a criminal case for a defect of proof or a material defect in the commitment, and is later arrested on sufficient proof and committed by legal process for the same offense, that isn't the same cause. If, in a civil action, the party was discharged for illegality in the judgment or process, and is afterward imprisoned by legal process for the same cause of action, that too falls outside the protection. And generally, whenever a discharge rests on a failure to observe required legal forms, the party may be imprisoned a second time if the underlying cause is legal and those forms are observed the second time around.

Taken together, these examples show the protection targets repeated confinement on the identical, uncorrected legal footing — not a properly corrected commitment that fixes whatever flaw led to the earlier discharge.

Frequently Asked Questions

What basic protection does Section 10-128 give a person discharged on habeas corpus?

Protection against being reimprisoned, restrained, or held in custody again for the same cause.

What two things can override that protection?

A later indictment for the same offense, or the legal order or process of the court where the person is bound by recognizance to appear.

Does correcting a defective commitment and rearresting on sufficient proof count as reimprisoning for the "same cause"?

No. Section 10-128 states that situation is not deemed the same cause.

Does Section 10-128 address civil custody as well as criminal custody?

Yes. It separately addresses a civil action discharge for illegality in the judgment or process, followed by lawful reimprisonment for the same cause of action.

What is the general principle behind all three carve-outs?

That a discharge for failing to observe required legal forms doesn't bar a second, properly formed imprisonment on a legal cause.

Amendment History

(Source: P.A. 82-280.)

Source & verification. Section text and amendment history are reproduced verbatim from the Illinois Compiled Statutes, published by the Illinois Compiled Statutes, Illinois General Assembly / Legislative Reference Bureau. Last verified July 20, 2026. · Official source
Also known as: reimprisonment after habeas corpus discharge illinoissame cause habeas corpus illinoisrearrest after discharge illinois habeas corpus