§ 2028.040.Objection to form of question; time to
Title 4. Civil Discovery Act · Chapter 11. Deposition by Written Questions · Enacted 2004 · no amendments on record · Last verified July 29, 2026
Full Text of § 2028.040
Plain-English Summary
Form objections in a written deposition work on a strict clock. A party who thinks a question is improperly phrased has to serve a specific objection to it, directed at every party entitled to notice, within 15 days after the question was served. Missing that window waives the objection entirely, so a party can't sit on a defective question and raise it for the first time after the deposition officer has already propounded it.
Raising the objection isn't the end of the process, though. The objecting party has to promptly move the court to sustain it, backed by a meet-and-confer declaration confirming the parties tried to resolve the dispute themselves first. Unless and until the court sustains the objection, the deposition officer still asks the deponent the question, just subject to that pending objection as to form. And there's a real cost to guessing wrong: the court has to impose a monetary sanction on whichever side loses the motion, whether that's the party who unsuccessfully sought to sustain the objection or the party who unsuccessfully opposed it, unless the losing side acted with substantial justification or a sanction would otherwise be unjust.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a party have to object to the form of a written-deposition question?
15 days after the question is served. Failing to object within that window waives the objection.
Does raising a form objection stop the deposition officer from asking the question?
No. Unless the court has sustained the objection, the officer still propounds the question, subject to the objection as to form.
What must accompany a motion to sustain a form objection?
A meet-and-confer declaration under Section 2016.040, showing the parties tried to resolve the dispute before involving the court.
Is there a penalty for losing a motion over a form objection?
Yes. The court must impose a monetary sanction against whoever unsuccessfully makes or opposes the motion, unless that party acted with substantial justification or a sanction would be unjust.
Amendment History
(Added by Stats.2004, c. 182 (A.B.3081), § 23, operative July 1, 2005.)