Art. 4.Same; Determination When Dependent On Amount In Dispute Or Value of Right Asserted
Title I. Courts · Chapter 1. Jurisdiction · Enacted 1995 · no amendments on record · Last verified July 30, 2026
Full Text of Art. 4
Amendment History
Acts 1995, No. 409, §1.
Plain-English Summary
When jurisdiction turns on a dollar figure, someone has to decide whose figure counts. Article 4 answers that: the plaintiff's demand controls, whether that's the specific amount claimed or, when no clean number applies, the value the plaintiff asserts in good faith for the right at stake.
The article also draws a line around what counts toward that figure. Interest, court costs, attorney fees, and penalties — whether they come from an agreement between the parties or from a statute — never count toward the jurisdictional amount, even when they add up to real money. Only the underlying demand does, along with certain exemplary damages the Civil Code allows in a narrow set of cases.
Good faith matters here. A plaintiff cannot inflate a claim to reach a higher court's docket, or deflate one to fit inside a limited-jurisdiction court, without a genuine basis for the number. The requirement protects the line Article 2 draws between courts of different reach.
Frequently Asked Questions
Whose estimate of a case's value determines jurisdiction?
The plaintiff's. Article 4 sets the jurisdictional amount as the amount demanded, or the value asserted in good faith by the plaintiff when there's no simple dollar figure.
Do attorney fees or court costs count toward the jurisdictional amount?
No. Article 4 excludes interest, court costs, attorney fees, and penalties from the calculation, regardless of whether they arise from an agreement or a statute.
Can a plaintiff inflate a claim to get into a higher court?
Not in good faith. Article 4 requires the amount or value asserted to reflect a real basis, so a demand pumped up without one doesn't create jurisdiction the court wouldn't otherwise have.
Do punitive-type damages count toward the jurisdictional amount?
Yes. Article 4 specifically includes the exemplary damages available under certain narrow Civil Code provisions as part of the amount demanded for jurisdictional purposes.