Rule 8.Reply Brief
Last verified June 30, 2026
Full Text of Rule 8
Amendment History
(Added Apr. 11, 2022, eff. Dec. 1, 2022.)
Plain-English Summary
The last word belongs to the plaintiff. Supplemental Rule 8 permits the plaintiff to file and serve a reply brief, responding to the Commissioner’s arguments, within 14 days after the Commissioner’s brief is filed. A reply is optional, but when filed it closes the briefing.
Once the briefs are in, the case is ready for decision on the record under Supplemental Rule 5 — no trial, no live testimony, just the administrative record and the parties’ written arguments. Together, Rules 5 through 8 give Social Security review cases a clean, uniform path from filing to decision.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can the plaintiff file a reply brief?
Yes. Supplemental Rule 8 allows a reply brief, filed and served within 14 days after the Commissioner’s brief.
Is a reply brief required?
No, it's optional. But once the reply period passes (or a reply is filed), briefing is closed and the case is ready for decision on the record under Supplemental Rule 5.