§ 639.Appointment When Parties Do Not Agree
Title 8. Of the Trial and Judgment In Civil Actions · Chapter 6. Of References and Trials by Referees · Last amended 2002 · Last verified July 28, 2026
Full Text of § 639
Plain-English Summary
When the parties don't agree to a reference, the court can still order one, but only in the situations subdivision (a) lists: an account too long to try conveniently, an accounting needed before judgment or to carry one out, a factual question arising outside the pleadings, information the court needs for a special proceeding, or — the category courts use most often — appointing a referee to hear and decide discovery motions and disputes and report recommendations.
Discovery references get their own procedural safeguards. A party can move to disqualify the assigned referee under § 170.6, generally within 10 days of the appointment notice or the party's appearance, or on a tighter timeline if the referee is known shortly before a scheduled hearing. Every appointment order, regardless of category, has to be in writing and state the reason for the reference (or, for discovery referees, the case-specific exceptional circumstances requiring it), the subject matter covered, the referee's name and contact information, and the referee's maximum hourly rate and, on request, a cap on hours.
Cost sits at the center of this section. The court can't appoint a referee at the parties' expense unless it finds either that no party has shown an inability to pay a pro rata share of the fees, or that a party who can't pay has another party willing to cover that share voluntarily. In judging inability to pay, the court looks only at the party's own resources, not counsel's — and a party proceeding in forma pauperis is deemed unable to pay as a matter of law.
Frequently Asked Questions
In what situations can a court appoint a referee over a party's objection?
When trial requires examining a long account, when an accounting is needed before or to carry out a judgment, when a non-pleading fact question arises, when information is needed for a special proceeding, or when the court needs a referee to hear and report on discovery motions and disputes.
Can a party challenge the referee assigned to a discovery dispute?
Yes, through a disqualification motion under § 170.6, generally within 10 days of the appointment notice or the party's appearance, or on a shorter timeline tied to the hearing date in some circumstances.
What must the court's order appointing a referee under this section include?
The reason for the reference (or the exceptional circumstances for a discovery referee), the subject matter, the referee's contact information, the maximum hourly rate, and a finding on the parties' ability to pay the fees.
Can a court appoint a paid referee if a party can't afford it?
Only if another party voluntarily agrees to cover that party's share — the court can't appoint a referee at cost to the parties without one of the required ability-to-pay findings.
Does being in forma pauperis affect the ability-to-pay finding?
Yes. A party proceeding in forma pauperis is automatically deemed to have an economic inability to pay the referee's fees.
Amendment History
Amended by Stats 2000 ch 644 (AB 2912), s 2.5, eff. 1/1/2001. Amended by Stats 2001 ch 362 (SB 475), s 1, eff. 1/1/2002.