Rule 33.4.Relationship Between Defense Counsel and Client
Rule 33. PLEADING BY DEFENDANT · Not amended since adoption on record · Last verified July 17, 2026
Full Text of Rule 33.4
Plain-English Summary
Rule 33.4 draws a clean line between what a lawyer can decide and what belongs to the client. Whatever ground the defense lawyer covers during negotiation, the final call on a plea deal stays with the defendant — counsel should lock one in only once the client has signed off on it.
To reach that decision, the defendant needs real information, not a lawyer’s guess. The rule tells defense counsel to dig into the case first, then walk the defendant through the choices available and whatever considerations counsel views as significant. The defendant weighs that advice and makes the call.
This division of labor keeps the lawyer in an advisory role while leaving the decision that carries the defendant’s constitutional rights — plead guilty, plead nolo contendere, or go to trial — where it belongs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who ultimately decides whether to accept a plea agreement?
The defendant. Rule 33.4(A) puts the final choice on whether to plead guilty or nolo contendere in the defendant’s hands, not counsel’s.
Can defense counsel finalize a plea agreement without the client’s approval?
No. Rule 33.4(A) says a plea deal should be locked in only once the defendant has agreed to it.
What must defense counsel do before advising a client on whether to plead?
Carry out appropriate investigation into the case first, per Rule 33.4(B).
What is defense counsel supposed to tell the defendant to help with the plea decision?
The choices available and whichever considerations counsel views as important to weighing them.
Does Rule 33.4 apply to both guilty pleas and nolo contendere pleas?
Yes — it covers whether the defendant chooses either kind of plea, or neither.