§ 9-13-172.When execution sale set aside
Chapter 13. Executions and Judicial Sales · Article 7. Judicial Sales · Last amended 1933 · Last verified July 17, 2026
Full Text of § 9-13-172
Plain-English Summary
The officer who conducts an execution sale — typically the sheriff — acts under the supervising court’s authority rather than independently, and this section states that supervisory relationship directly: courts have full power over their officers making execution sales.
Once the court is satisfied that a sale is infected with fraud, irregularity, or error to the injury of either party, setting the sale aside is not left to the court’s discretion — the statute says the court “shall” do it. The three grounds are distinct (fraud, irregularity, and error each describe a different kind of problem), but all three share the same limiting condition: the defect has to have injured one of the parties, not merely amounted to a technical slip that hurt no one.
This section works alongside several others that map out when a flawed sale stands and when it falls. Code Section 9-13-172.1 supplies its own rescission-and-damages framework for a narrower category of sales the seller itself chooses to rescind before delivering the deed. Code Section 9-13-171 addresses when a defendant’s own silence at the sale can bind him despite a defect in the underlying process. And Code Section 9-13-168 keeps an innocent purchaser’s own diligence duty narrow, so that irregularities of the kind this section addresses remain a matter between the officer and the parties, not grounds to unwind the sale against a purchaser who did nothing wrong.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who has authority to set aside a defective execution sale?
The court, which the statute says has full power over its own officers making execution sales.
Is setting aside a flawed sale left to the court’s discretion?
No. Once the court is satisfied the sale is infected with fraud, irregularity, or error injuring either party, the statute states that the court shall set it aside.
What kinds of defects can support setting aside a sale?
Fraud, irregularity, or error, provided the defect injured either party to the sale.
Does a technical irregularity that hurt no one justify setting aside a sale?
The statute conditions relief on injury to either party, so a defect that caused no harm would not meet this section’s standard.
Does this section apply to a rescission by the seller before the deed is delivered?
That specific situation is addressed separately by Code Section 9-13-172.1, which sets its own rules and damages caps for an “eligible sale.”
Amendment History
Civil Code 1895, § 5427; Civil Code 1910, § 6032; Code 1933, § 39-1316.