Rule 44.Physical and Mental Examination of Persons; Reports of Examinations
Current through June 1, 2026 · Last verified July 11, 2026
Full Text of Rule 44
Amendment History
[CCP 12/2/78; §§ A, E amended by 1979 c.284 §§ 27, 28; § E amended by CCP 12/4/82; § C amended by CCP 12/13/86; §§ C, E amended by CCP 12/10/88 and 1/6/89; §§ A, B, D amended by 1989 c.1084 § 2 ; § E amended by CCP 12/14/02 eff. 1/1/04; § E amended by CCP 12/8/18 eff. 1/1/20]
Plain-English Summary
Rule 44 lets a court order a party — or someone in that party’s custody or legal control, such as an employee, or a spouse in a case seeking damages for injury to the spouse — to undergo a physical or mental examination when that person’s physical or mental condition, or a disputed blood relationship, is in controversy in the case. This is not automatic discovery like a document request; it takes a motion, a showing of good cause, and notice to both the person being examined and every party. The resulting order has to spell out the specifics: when and where the exam happens, how it will be conducted, any conditions on it, its scope, and who performs it.
Once an exam happens, the rule builds in a trade. If the examined person or the party against whom the order was made asks for it, the party who arranged the exam has to hand over a detailed report covering the examiner’s findings, test results, diagnoses, and conclusions, along with reports from any earlier exams of the same condition. Handing that report over then entitles the arranging party to ask for the other side’s own reports on that same condition. Separately, and without needing any court order at all, a party who sues for damages for personal injury has to turn over copies of all written reports and existing notations from any exam relating to the injuries at issue, if the defending party asks — unless the claimant can show an inability to get them. When no written report exists yet, the party who owes one has to ask the examiner to prepare it and cover the reasonable cost of doing so. A party, physician, or psychologist who will not cooperate risks having the court order a deposition of the examiner or exclude that examiner’s testimony at trial.
Section E addresses confidential health information more broadly. A party defending against a claim for injury-related damages can obtain the confidential health information defined in Rule 55 D, so long as it falls within the discovery scope set by Rule 36 B, through a written patient authorization, a court order, or a subpoena issued under Rule 55 D.
Frequently Asked Questions
When can a court order me to undergo a physical or mental exam?
Only when your physical or mental condition, or a blood relationship, is in controversy in the case, and only after the other side files a motion showing good cause. The court cannot order an exam on request alone — it has to issue an order specifying the time, place, manner, conditions, and scope of the exam and naming who will perform it, and it has to give notice to you and every party first.
Who besides a party can be ordered to undergo an examination?
Rule 44 A reaches beyond the named party to anyone in that party’s custody or legal control, including an agent or employee, and specifically includes the spouse of a party in a case seeking damages for injury to the spouse. If the person to be examined is not the party, the party can instead be ordered to produce that person for the exam.
If I’m examined, can I get a copy of the report?
Yes. If you request it, the party who arranged the examination has to deliver a detailed report of the examiner’s findings, including test results, diagnoses, and conclusions, along with reports from any earlier exams of the same condition. Once that report is delivered, the arranging party can in turn request your own reports on the same condition, past or future — with a narrow exception if you can show you cannot obtain a non-party’s exam report.
Does a personal injury claimant have to turn over medical reports even without a Rule 44 order?
Yes, under section C. Once a defending party asks, a claimant seeking damages for injuries has to deliver copies of all written reports and existing notations from any examination relating to the injuries claimed, regardless of whether a court ever ordered an examination. The claimant is excused only by showing an inability to comply.
What happens if a report doesn’t exist yet or someone won’t produce one?
If a report is owed under section B or C but the examiner never wrote one, the obligated party has to ask the examiner to prepare a written report and pay the reasonable cost of preparing it. If a party still fails to comply, or the examiner refuses to produce a report within a reasonable time, the court can order the examiner to sit for a deposition or exclude the examiner’s testimony at trial.