Rule 39.Trial by Jury or by the Court
Current through June 1, 2026 · Last verified July 10, 2026
Full Text of Rule 39
Amendment History
Repealed and readopted July 12, 1990, effective September 1, 1990.
Plain-English Summary
Rule 39 puts a jury demand made under Rule 38 into effect. Once a party has demanded a jury and paid the fee, the case is marked on the register of actions as a jury action, and every issue the demand covers goes to the jury — unless one of three things happens: everyone who paid the fee and never waived agrees in writing to give up the jury, the court decides on its own or on a party's motion that no right to a jury trial exists for those issues, or the parties who demanded the jury fail to appear at trial.
Issues nobody demanded for a jury are tried by the judge alone under Rule 39(b). That is the default position under Rule 38: silence means the judge decides.
For cases that aren't otherwise entitled to a jury, Rule 39(c) gives the court two more options. It can convene an advisory jury on its own initiative or on motion — the jury hears the evidence and gives its view, but the judge still decides the case and is not bound by what the jury says. Or, with both parties' consent, the court can hold a jury trial whose verdict is binding, as if the right to a jury existed in the first place. The one exception: in a suit against the State of Colorado, the court cannot do this when a statute requires the case to be tried without a jury.
Frequently Asked Questions
What does it mean for a case to be designated a "jury action"?
Once a jury trial has been properly demanded and the jury fee paid under Rule 38, the case is marked on the register of actions as a jury action, and the demanded issues are tried by a jury unless the case falls into one of the exceptions in Rule 39(a).
Can a jury trial be canceled after it has been demanded?
Yes, in three situations: every entitled party agrees in writing to waive the jury, the court determines that no right to a jury trial exists on those issues, or the parties who demanded the jury fail to appear at trial.
What is an advisory jury?
In a case that would otherwise be tried to the judge alone, the court may still convene a jury to hear the evidence and offer its findings. But that jury's verdict is not binding — the judge decides the case regardless of what the advisory jury recommends.
Can parties agree to a jury trial in a case that would not otherwise get one?
Yes. With the consent of both parties, the court may order a binding jury trial even in a case not normally triable to a jury — except in a suit against the State of Colorado where a statute requires a bench trial.